Recruitment Fee Structures: Contingency vs. Retained Recruiting and Their Impact on Job Seekers

Contingency vs. Retained Recruiting Comparison

Understanding How Recruiters Get Paid

Recruitment is an essential part of any business, as it is responsible for finding and selecting the most qualified candidates for a job. However, the process of how recruiters get paid and how it affects job candidates is often not fully understood. In this article, we will explore the different ways recruiters get paid and how it impacts job seekers.

Contingency Recruiting

Contingency recruiting is the most common form of recruiting, where a recruiter is paid a percentage of the candidate’s first-year salary. The fee is typically around 15-25% of the candidate’s total compensation, and it is only paid if the recruiter successfully places the candidate in the job. This means that the recruiter is not paid unless they find a suitable candidate for the role.

In contingency recruiting, recruiters work on a commission basis and are usually in competition with other recruiters to find the best talent for a specific job opening. Companies that use contingency recruiters typically have a high volume of job openings and are looking for a quick turnaround time in filling the role. This method is often used for lower and mid-level positions where there is a large pool of candidates available.

Retained Recruiting

Retained recruiting is a more specialized form of recruiting, where a recruiter is hired on an exclusive basis to find a candidate for a specific role. In retained recruiting, the company pays a portion of the fee upfront to the recruiter, with the remainder paid upon successful placement. The fee is typically higher than in contingency recruiting, usually around 30-35% of the candidate’s first-year salary.

In retained recruiting, the recruiter works closely with the hiring company to understand the requirements of the role and the company culture. The recruiter conducts a thorough search and provides a shortlist of top candidates to the company. The company is then free to select the best candidate from the list. Retained recruiting is often used for executive-level positions, where the company is looking for a highly specialized skill set, and confidentiality is crucial.

Comparing Contingency and Retained Recruiting

Both contingency and retained recruiting have their pros and cons, and the choice of method depends on the company’s needs and preferences.

Pros and Cons of Contingency Recruiting

Contingency recruiting is faster and more affordable, but it can result in a high volume of unqualified candidates, and the company might not have access to the best talent available.

Pros and Cons of Retained Recruiting

Retained recruiting, on the other hand, provides access to highly specialized talent and offers a more customized approach to recruiting. However, it is more expensive and can take longer to fill the role. Ultimately, the decision between contingency and retained recruiting comes down to the level of expertise required for the role, the company’s budget, and the timeline for filling the position.

The Impact of Recruitment Fees on Job Candidates

The most common way recruiters get paid is through a contingency fee, which means they only get paid if they successfully place a candidate in a job. The fee is usually a percentage of the candidate’s first-year salary, ranging from 15% to 25%. This fee structure incentivizes recruiters to find the best candidates for the job and negotiate a higher salary for them.

However, this fee structure can have negative consequences for job candidates. Recruiters may prioritize finding a candidate who will accept a lower salary to maximize their commission. This can lead to candidates being undervalued and not receiving the compensation they deserve.

Another way recruiters get paid is through a retained search, where the recruiter is paid a fee upfront to conduct a search for a specific position. This fee is usually a percentage of the position’s salary, ranging from 30% to 35%. The retained search fee structure incentivizes recruiters to find the best candidate for the job, regardless of the salary they negotiate.

However, this fee structure can be costly for companies and may limit the number of positions they choose to fill through a retained search. This, in turn, can limit the opportunities for job candidates to be considered for these roles.

Recruiters may also receive bonuses or commissions for meeting certain targets, such as filling a specific number of positions within a set time frame. These bonuses or commissions can motivate recruiters to work harder to find the best candidates for the job. However, it can also lead to recruiters being incentivized to fill positions quickly rather than finding the most qualified candidate.

In addition to how recruiters get paid, it is also important to consider the impact of recruitment fees on job candidates. Some companies may pass on the cost of recruitment fees to the job candidate by offering a lower salary or benefits package. This can be frustrating for job seekers who may not understand why they are being offered a lower salary or fewer benefits than expected.

Furthermore, job candidates may feel pressure to accept a job offer due to the cost of the recruitment fee. If a company has already paid a recruitment fee for a candidate, they may feel compelled to accept the job offer, even if it is not the best fit for them.

Navigating the Recruitment Process Effectively

In conclusion, understanding how recruiters get paid is crucial for job candidates to navigate the recruitment process effectively. The fee structure can have both positive and negative impacts on job seekers, and it is essential to be aware of these implications to make informed decisions. Ultimately, the goal of recruitment should be to find the most qualified candidate for the job, rather than maximizing profits for recruiters or companies.



Master of Arts (M.A.) Columbia University – Business/Organization Psychology
#1 Recommended Executive Resume Writer
400+ Recommendations on LinkedIn | 500+ 5 Star Reviews on Other Platforms
Nationally Certified Resume Writer (NCRW) | Multi-Certified Resume Writer
NCRW: Deemed Ph.D. of Resume Writing/Top 99.9% of Resume Writers
Board Certified & Credentialed Career Coach (BCC, PCC-ICF)