{ "version": "Final editorial scoring v1.0", "research_cutoff": "2026-10-26", "market": "Human-led résumé-writing services serving U.S. job seekers; fixed 25-provider cohort inherited from earlier 49-company screening. Not an exhaustive current census.", "weights": [ { "id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "definition": "Specificity, consistency, relevance and recency of customer accounts; independent platforms plus attributable company-maintained records. Review count alone does not set the score." }, { "id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "definition": "Specific interviews, offers, transitions, repeat engagements and referrals. Attributed outcomes earn credit without a causal success-rate claim; aggregate marketing percentages do not." }, { "id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "definition": "Published offer relative to the work and service depth, clear scope and commercial commitments. Normal discounts are accepted. Quote-based work is evaluated on scope and terms, not an invented price." }, { "id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "definition": "Discovery, targeting, human access, authorship accountability and package completeness for the intended customer; not the raw number of add-ons." }, { "id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "definition": "Relevant preparation, experience and verifiable credentials of the person doing the work; founder credentials are not transferred to an entire roster." }, { "id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "definition": "Achievement development, targeting, narrative, clarity, readability and proofreading in inspected examples; supported by editorial process and concrete customer observations. Inspection coverage is separately identified." }, { "id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "definition": "Severity, repetition and service relevance of disputes; responsiveness, access, correction rights and remedies. No observed complaint is neither zero performance nor proof of perfection." }, { "id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "definition": "Operating continuity, sustained practice and experienced personnel. Longer history is useful but cannot overcome poor present-day delivery." }, { "id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "definition": "External professional contribution and recognition, separately from credentials and customer stars. Paid rankings and a company calling itself best do not earn credit." } ], "companies": [ { "id": "C09", "name": "Ivy League Résumés", "ratings": [ 9, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 9, 9, 8.5, 8.5, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 88.25, "score_display": 88, "audience": "Direct expert professional and executive service", "advertised_price": "$499.95–$895 published customized tiers", "strength": "Strong combination of named expertise, detailed feedback and value", "limitation": "Cross-brand archive is not a résumé-only audited customer census", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Selected complete two-page COO example inspected", "services": "Customized resumes, letters, LinkedIn and practitioner career support", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 18.0, "rationale": "A large source-associated archive and independent review evidence contain unusually detailed service accounts; mixed-service records are not all résumé purchases.", "source_ids": [ "S041" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 12.75, "rationale": "Specific interviews, offers, return engagements and referrals support a strong track record; no-claim guarantee history is not a 100% success rate.", "source_ids": [ "S041" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 13.5, "rationale": "Published customized-package prices are strong relative to named-expert discovery and coordinated documents; automated tiers are excluded.", "source_ids": [ "S046" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 9.5, "rationale": "Direct practitioner discovery, writing and follow-up create unusually clear authorship accountability and individualized positioning.", "source_ids": [ "S041", "S044" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Current issuer-listed NCRW and relevant graduate/professional preparation are connected to the named delivery practitioner.", "source_ids": [ "S044", "S045" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "The inspected COO résumé connects executive scope, progression and business impact; dense passages and chart labeling are minor limitations.", "source_ids": [ "S043" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Detailed responsiveness accounts and a defined support/guarantee approach support a strong rating; no universal no-complaint claim is assumed.", "source_ids": [ "S041", "S046" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "A long founder-led practice and multi-year returning-client evidence support continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S044", "S041" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "An externally hosted alumni career-coach profile supports professional participation; it is not a university endorsement or a best-writer award.", "source_ids": [ "S045" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S041", "S043", "S044", "S045", "S046" ], "rank": 1, "wins": 24, "losses": 0, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [] }, { "id": "C18", "name": "Career Impressions", "ratings": [ 8.5, 8, 8, 9.5, 9, 8.5, 8, 8.5, 8.5 ], "score_exact": 84.5, "score_display": 85, "audience": "Direct executive résumé and LinkedIn strategy", "advertised_price": "CAD 1,295–2,095 résumé; CAD 1,895–2,695 with LinkedIn", "strength": "Named CERM practitioner and substantive executive positioning", "limitation": "Selected outcome accounts; prices are Canadian dollars", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "One selected COO excerpt visually inspected", "services": "Executive resume, LinkedIn, letters and branding tiers", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Detailed executive client narratives support high satisfaction; the selected testimonial collection is not a complete independent census.", "source_ids": [ "S085" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Specific screening, interview, promotion and offer accounts support a strong track record.", "source_ids": [ "S085" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Tiered executive scope and direct specialist service support good value; prices remain in Canadian dollars.", "source_ids": [ "S084" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 9.5, "rationale": "Personal delivery, worksheet and strategic conversation provide unusually strong targeted engagement.", "source_ids": [ "S084" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "The named delivery practitioner is listed by the issuer as a Certified Executive Resume Master.", "source_ids": [ "S088" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "The inspected COO excerpt connects operating scale with outcomes; the review covers an excerpt, not the entire engagement.", "source_ids": [ "S087" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed service and follow-up accounts support care; current dispute-specific evidence is limited and does not establish perfection.", "source_ids": [ "S085" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "A long-running specialist practice and multi-year professional record support continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S084", "S120" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "Historical award results issued by the association support professional recognition separately from the CERM qualification.", "source_ids": [ "S120" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S084", "S085", "S087", "S088", "S120" ], "rank": 2, "wins": 23, "losses": 1, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C15", "C13" ] }, { "id": "C15", "name": "An Expert Resume", "ratings": [ 8.5, 8.5, 7.5, 9.5, 9, 8, 8, 9, 8.5 ], "score_exact": 84.25, "score_display": 84, "audience": "Senior technical, healthcare and executive clients", "advertised_price": "$1,797 résumé; rush option separate", "strength": "Exclusive senior-expert authorship and detailed outcome accounts", "limitation": "Premium cost; no complete visual sample assessment", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Executive resume, LinkedIn, biography and branding options", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Detailed selected customer accounts describe intensive collaboration and repeat work; the record is not an independent random sample.", "source_ids": [ "S073" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 12.75, "rationale": "Specific interview and offer stories across repeat engagements provide strong attributed outcome evidence.", "source_ids": [ "S073" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "The high published résumé price buys exclusive senior-expert work and a long interview; this is narrower value for budget buyers.", "source_ids": [ "S071" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 9.5, "rationale": "Exclusive authorship and a lengthy branding interview create unusually clear expert accountability and depth.", "source_ids": [ "S071", "S072" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Named technical/recruiting experience, professional preparation and publication history support strong expert delivery; every current certification was not rechecked.", "source_ids": [ "S072", "S119" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed discovery and customer descriptions support high process quality; a complete sample was not visually assessed in the retained audit.", "source_ids": [ "S072", "S073" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Direct follow-up and repeat relationships support service commitment; precise current cash-remedy evidence is less complete.", "source_ids": [ "S071", "S073" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "External publisher and company records support a long-running career-writing practice; differing historical founding references are not collapsed into a false exact date.", "source_ids": [ "S119", "S072" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "External publication work and independently announced historical résumé awards support strong professional standing.", "source_ids": [ "S119", "S120" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S071", "S072", "S073", "S119", "S120" ], "rank": 3, "wins": 22, "losses": 2, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C18", "C13", "C17" ] }, { "id": "C13", "name": "Distinctive Career Services", "ratings": [ 8, 8, 7.5, 8.5, 8.5, 9, 8, 9.5, 9.5 ], "score_exact": 82.75, "score_display": 83, "audience": "Executive branding and complex career narratives", "advertised_price": "Individual quote; old guide is not a current fixed price", "strength": "Substantive portfolio and exceptional professional contribution", "limitation": "Historical survey and sample; current quote required", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Selected complete three-page CEO example inspected", "services": "Resume and executive branding, LinkedIn, career documents", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Detailed testimonials and a disclosed historical customer survey provide substantive support, though they are company-selected and dated.", "source_ids": [ "S060" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Repeat engagements, referrals and career-transition accounts support a durable track record without a current population outcome claim.", "source_ids": [ "S060" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Quoted branding engagements have meaningful depth; value is judged on scope and terms, not an invented current fixed price.", "source_ids": [ "S060", "S061" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Detailed career branding and clarification support substantial customization, with a team rather than universally exclusive founder authorship.", "source_ids": [ "S061", "S117" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Founder preparation and professional leadership are strong; the old NCRW renewal field is unresolved and does not certify every team writer.", "source_ids": [ "S117" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "The inspected three-page CEO sample demonstrates substantive turnaround and acquisition narratives; density and historical age limit generalization.", "source_ids": [ "S062", "S063", "S064" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed service accounts and iterative collaboration support care; current dispute-specific independent evidence remains limited.", "source_ids": [ "S060" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 4.75, "rationale": "Long practice continuity and the historical survey/portfolio record support a mature business.", "source_ids": [ "S060", "S117" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 4.75, "rationale": "Independent NRWA awards and historical association competition recognition establish unusually strong professional contribution.", "source_ids": [ "S066", "S120" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S060", "S061", "S062", "S063", "S064", "S066", "S117", "S120" ], "rank": 4, "wins": 21, "losses": 3, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C18", "C15", "C17", "C20", "C05" ] }, { "id": "C17", "name": "The Writing Guru", "ratings": [ 8, 8, 7, 9.5, 9, 8.5, 8, 8.5, 9.5 ], "score_exact": 82.5, "score_display": 83, "audience": "Senior legal, board and C-suite candidates", "advertised_price": "$3,995 executive / $4,995 board / $5,995 combined", "strength": "Direct legal-domain writer with strong external recognition", "limitation": "High cost and booking lead time; one credential-status discrepancy", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Redacted example policy and process; no full visual sample", "services": "Executive and board resumes, bios, LinkedIn, personal branding", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Detailed legal/executive customer accounts support satisfaction, while the broader review total remains a company-reported figure.", "source_ids": [ "S082" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Specific selected interview/offer and repeat-client accounts support effectiveness without a placement-rate claim.", "source_ids": [ "S082" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Intensive legal/board branding can justify premium scope, but high entry cost and booking lead time narrow value and accessibility.", "source_ids": [ "S079" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 9.5, "rationale": "Exclusive personal authorship, discovery and legal/board targeting provide unusually strong practitioner accountability.", "source_ids": [ "S121" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Current NCRW plus legal and teaching background support elite relevant preparation; NCOPE is not credited as currently verified.", "source_ids": [ "S080", "S121" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Writing-intensive professional background, explicit editorial work and detailed client accounts support strong process quality; redacted examples were not fully visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S082", "S083" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Direct expert access and customer accounts support care; private dispute incidence and final cash remedies are not assumed.", "source_ids": [ "S079", "S082" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "An established practice since 2010 is supported by the ABA announcement and company history.", "source_ids": [ "S116" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 4.75, "rationale": "The ABA service-to-profession award and substantial externally published professional work support exceptional standing, not a best-résumé award.", "source_ids": [ "S116" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S079", "S080", "S082", "S083", "S116", "S121" ], "rank": 5, "wins": 20, "losses": 4, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C15", "C13", "C20", "C05", "C02" ] }, { "id": "C20", "name": "Career Steering", "ratings": [ 8.5, 8, 7.5, 9.5, 8.5, 8, 7.5, 9, 8 ], "score_exact": 82.25, "score_display": 82, "audience": "C-suite and senior executive direct authorship", "advertised_price": "$1,695 résumé; $2,595 / $3,495 broader retained offers", "strength": "Direct expert delivery and sustained repeat relationships", "limitation": "Premium cost, longer production and no-refund conditions", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Executive resume, LinkedIn, biography and multiple-format branding", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Detailed source-associated reviews include repeat executive work and responsive service.", "source_ids": [ "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Specific career-progress and repeat-use accounts support a strong track record; the advertised referral percentage is not treated as audited.", "source_ids": [ "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "A premium résumé price buys direct senior-practitioner discovery; longer timing and no-refund terms narrow the value proposition.", "source_ids": [ "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 9.5, "rationale": "Named practitioner involvement through discovery and writing provides unusually strong accountability.", "source_ids": [ "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "A named expert with historical association-documented master-writer background supports strong preparation; current renewal of every credential is not assumed.", "source_ids": [ "S118", "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed customer descriptions and explicit process support strong craftsmanship; no complete résumé was visually assessed in the retained audit.", "source_ids": [ "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Direct access and repeat customers are favorable, while no-refund conditions limit the commercial remedy.", "source_ids": [ "S093" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "Historical association publications, awards and continuing service support a long-running practice.", "source_ids": [ "S118", "S120" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "Historical association awards and published professional contributions support standing independently of customer stars.", "source_ids": [ "S120", "S118" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S093", "S118", "S120" ], "rank": 6, "wins": 19, "losses": 5, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C13", "C17", "C05", "C02", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C12" ] }, { "id": "C05", "name": "ResumeSpice", "ratings": [ 9, 8, 8, 8.5, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 7.5, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 82.0, "score_display": 82, "audience": "Consultation-led professional and executive writing", "advertised_price": "$479 entry; $589 professional; $699 executive résumé", "strength": "Strong independent customer experience and clear consultation", "limitation": "Employee-only FAQ conflicts with contractor-permitting terms", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, letters, LinkedIn, interview/career support", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 18.0, "rationale": "Extensive recent independent accounts strongly support positive service experience; an occasional critical review is not ignored.", "source_ids": [ "S024" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Interview and offer accounts support a strong practical record; coaching-only experiences are not counted as résumé outcomes.", "source_ids": [ "S024" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Clear tier prices and consultation deliver substantial scope; the full résumé/letter/LinkedIn combination is not a budget offering.", "source_ids": [ "S020" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Phone discovery, named consultant interaction and revisions provide a structured personalized engagement.", "source_ids": [ "S020", "S021" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Recruiter-informed standards support competence, but internal certification is not automatically an externally issued credential; staffing statements differ.", "source_ids": [ "S021", "S022" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed customer descriptions and editing process support a strong quality judgment; no full selected document was visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S021", "S024" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Zero displayed formal BBB complaints plus responsive customer accounts support a strong service-recovery rating; refunds are restrictive.", "source_ids": [ "S023", "S022" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "An established service and multi-year customer record support stability; it is younger than the longest-running specialists.", "source_ids": [ "S024" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "Recruiting-related professional positioning is relevant, while star totals and company marketing are not independent industry awards.", "source_ids": [ "S021", "S024" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S020", "S021", "S022", "S023", "S024" ], "rank": 7, "wins": 18, "losses": 6, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C13", "C17", "C20", "C02", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C12", "C01" ] }, { "id": "C02", "name": "Find My Profession", "ratings": [ 8.5, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 8, 8.5, 8, 7.5, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 80.75, "score_display": 81, "audience": "Professionals and managers", "advertised_price": "$595 résumé; $895 résumé + cover letter + LinkedIn", "strength": "Substantive inspected work and structured collaboration", "limitation": "Writing outcomes must be separated from reverse recruiting", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Selected complete two-page example inspected", "services": "Resume, LinkedIn, letters, executive/federal options; recruiting separate", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Broad independent feedback supports responsiveness and positive writing experiences; recruiting-only accounts are excluded from résumé judgments.", "source_ids": [ "S123" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Specific interviews and offers support a useful track record, but many accounts combine writing with recruiting or coaching.", "source_ids": [ "S123" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Professional package and component prices are clear; the fuller document combination costs more than some comparable options.", "source_ids": [ "S005" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "A consultation, direct assigned-writer access and targeted documents provide substantial customization.", "source_ids": [ "S005" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "A specialist writer roster and disclosed expertise support a strong rating; the purchaser-specific credential is not confirmed.", "source_ids": [ "S005" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "The inspected program-manager example connects business scope with outcomes; dense passages are its principal visible weakness.", "source_ids": [ "S007", "S008" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Published revision access supports recovery; the reviewed BBB cases must not all be treated as résumé-writing failures.", "source_ids": [ "S005", "S009" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "A sustained active offer and established customer history support stability without an assumed multi-decade tenure.", "source_ids": [ "S005", "S123" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "Professional visibility is credible; its own competitor rankings and recruiting success do not establish independent writing supremacy.", "source_ids": [ "S005", "S009" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S005", "S007", "S008", "S009", "S123" ], "rank": 8, "wins": 17, "losses": 7, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C17", "C20", "C05", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C12", "C01", "C22", "C21" ] }, { "id": "C25", "name": "Employment BOOST", "ratings": [ 8.5, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 8, 8, 8, 8, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 80.5, "score_display": 81, "audience": "Team-based writing with outplacement support", "advertised_price": "$749 executive résumé + cover-letter package", "strength": "Recent named customers corroborate writing and follow-up", "limitation": "Many reviews include employer-funded outplacement/coaching", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, LinkedIn, letters, interview coaching and corporate outplacement", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Eight recent named SHRM-directory accounts corroborate attentive support; broader outplacement reviews are not all standalone résumé orders.", "source_ids": [ "S115" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Specific interviews and jobs are reported, but coaching and employer-sponsored outplacement often contributed to those outcomes.", "source_ids": [ "S115" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "The published executive package combines consultation, résumé and letter at a competitive team-service price.", "source_ids": [ "S105" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "An hour-long intake, revisions and coordinated career support provide substantial customization.", "source_ids": [ "S105" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "The company describes degree-qualified, CPRW-trained in-house writers and recruiter review; this is not an audit of every assigned writer.", "source_ids": [ "S105", "S106" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Concrete customer descriptions of targeting and editorial work corroborate the process; no full portfolio was visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S105", "S115" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Recent named accounts support responsiveness and ongoing care; private disputes and cash remedies are not inferred from a platform rating.", "source_ids": [ "S115", "S105" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "The established operating service, external business record and multi-year customer evidence support continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S107", "S115" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "An external HR vendor-directory presence and recruiting connections support professional standing; directory inclusion is not SHRM endorsement.", "source_ids": [ "S115", "S106" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S105", "S106", "S107", "S115" ], "rank": 9, "wins": 13, "losses": 8, "ties": 3, "close_neighbors": [ "C20", "C05", "C02", "C10", "C06", "C12", "C01", "C22", "C21" ] }, { "id": "C10", "name": "JobStars USA", "ratings": [ 8.5, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 8, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 80.5, "score_display": 81, "audience": "Clients valuing extended collaboration", "advertised_price": "$495–$895 Bronze; broader tiers up to $1,495", "strength": "Thirty-day revisions and attentive boutique support", "limitation": "Assigned-writer qualification and complete sample not verified", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, thank-you/reference documents, LinkedIn and distribution tiers", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Detailed BBB customer accounts support communication and care, with a smaller review footprint than the large platforms.", "source_ids": [ "S050" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Interview, job and repeat-use accounts support practical benefit; distribution-assisted outcomes are not résumé-only causal evidence.", "source_ids": [ "S050" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Clearly scoped tiers and a 30-day revision period support good value; higher bundles include additional services rather than a cheaper equivalent.", "source_ids": [ "S047", "S048" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Phone intake, direct correspondence and a long same-target revision window support substantial personalization.", "source_ids": [ "S047" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Relevant owner credentials and professional scope are described; assigned-writer issuer status is not established for every engagement.", "source_ids": [ "S047", "S048" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Process detail and substantive customer descriptions support strong quality control; no full visual example was assessed in this review.", "source_ids": [ "S047", "S050" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Zero displayed BBB complaints, responsive accounts and extended revisions support a strong service-support judgment.", "source_ids": [ "S049", "S050", "S047" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "A sustained boutique operation and repeat/family-use accounts support continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S050", "S048" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "A credible professional presence is supported; BBB stars themselves are not professional awards.", "source_ids": [ "S048", "S050" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S047", "S048", "S049", "S050" ], "rank": 10, "wins": 13, "losses": 8, "ties": 3, "close_neighbors": [ "C20", "C05", "C02", "C25", "C06", "C12", "C01", "C22", "C21" ] }, { "id": "C06", "name": "Great Resumes Fast", "ratings": [ 8, 7.5, 8, 9, 8, 8.5, 7.5, 8.5, 8 ], "score_exact": 80.5, "score_display": 81, "audience": "Executive positioning with a specialist team", "advertised_price": "$895–$1,095 résumé; $1,395–$1,695 branding ranges", "strength": "Strong examined executive narrative and deep discovery", "limitation": "Aggregate outcome statistics lack complete methods", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Selected complete two-page executive example inspected", "services": "Executive resume, LinkedIn, biography/branding and support packages", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Detailed favorable and repeat-client reviews support the customer case; communication and targeting criticisms temper consistency.", "source_ids": [ "S027" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Individual career-progress accounts count; promotional interview and offer percentages do not receive unearned statistical credit.", "source_ids": [ "S025", "S027" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Substantial executive discovery and document development support the published price bands; offers are compared by scope rather than sale status.", "source_ids": [ "S025", "S026" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "A lengthy discovery interview, specialist writing and editorial collaboration support deep customization.", "source_ids": [ "S025" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Relevant founder preparation is documented; it cannot certify every assigned team writer.", "source_ids": [ "S122", "S025" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "The inspected executive sample develops business transformation and impact; density and small proofreading issues limit a higher grade.", "source_ids": [ "S028" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Revision rights and customer support are evident, but critical communication accounts and conditional assurances limit the recovery judgment.", "source_ids": [ "S025", "S027" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "An established executive practice and repeat-customer history support continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S025", "S027" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "Issuer-hosted professional presence and industry contribution support standing; self-promotional best-service claims are not treated as independent awards.", "source_ids": [ "S122" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S025", "S026", "S027", "S028", "S122" ], "rank": 11, "wins": 13, "losses": 8, "ties": 3, "close_neighbors": [ "C20", "C05", "C02", "C25", "C10", "C12", "C01", "C22", "C21" ] }, { "id": "C12", "name": "iCareerSolutions", "ratings": [ 8, 7.5, 8, 9, 8.5, 8, 8, 8, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 80.5, "score_display": 81, "audience": "Technology and executive career positioning", "advertised_price": "$495 / $795 / $1,295 professional tiers", "strength": "Substantial consultation and corrected favorable BBB record", "limitation": "Older independent review sample; outcome claims unsubstantiated", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, letters, LinkedIn, executive branding; recruiting separate", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Specific favorable accounts and the current BBB record support a strong experience case; Trustpilot recency is limited.", "source_ids": [ "S059", "S057" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Detailed customer outcomes support benefit; salary/interview percentages and recruiting outcomes are not treated as résumé-only measured results.", "source_ids": [ "S059", "S055" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Professional tiers combine substantive intake with coordinated documents at competitive prices for that depth.", "source_ids": [ "S055" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Substantial consultation and senior-writer involvement support unusually individualized professional positioning.", "source_ids": [ "S055" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Specialist expertise and founder involvement support a strong rating; not every advertised award or assigned-writer credential is independently verified.", "source_ids": [ "S055" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Customer descriptions of careful discovery and editing corroborate a strong process; no complete sample was visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S059", "S055" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "The current zero-complaint BBB record is favorable; nonrefundable writing terms keep support below the most flexible arrangements.", "source_ids": [ "S058", "S056" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "The sustained specialist practice and older detailed customer accounts support an established operating history.", "source_ids": [ "S059", "S055" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "Professional visibility is credible; founder-linked association recognition is not treated as wholly independent validation.", "source_ids": [ "S055", "S057" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S055", "S056", "S057", "S058", "S059" ], "rank": 12, "wins": 13, "losses": 8, "ties": 3, "close_neighbors": [ "C20", "C05", "C02", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C01", "C22", "C21" ] }, { "id": "C01", "name": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "ratings": [ 8.5, 8, 8.5, 8, 7.5, 8, 7.5, 7.5, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 80.25, "score_display": 80, "audience": "Midcareer and career change", "advertised_price": "$439 Starter; $689 Premium; $889 Transform", "strength": "Consultative documents with editorial support", "limitation": "Short standard revision window; assigned expertise varies", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, letters, LinkedIn; executive and coaching options", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Detailed recent accounts describe attentive collaboration; meaningful independent review coverage, with some critical experiences.", "source_ids": [ "S003", "S004" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Individual advancement and interview accounts plus repeat use support effectiveness; no guarantee is treated as a success rate.", "source_ids": [ "S001", "S003" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 12.75, "rationale": "The published Premium bundle includes the three main documents and a consultation at a competitive midmarket price.", "source_ids": [ "S001", "S002" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Consultation and writer communication support customization; standard scope is less intensive than the deepest executive engagements.", "source_ids": [ "S001" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Defined writing/editorial team and founder preparation provide a credible capability base; assigned-writer credentials are not universally verified.", "source_ids": [ "S001" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Editorial review and specific customer descriptions support strong process quality; no full sample was visually assessed in the retained audit.", "source_ids": [ "S001", "S003" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "A written satisfaction process exists; the short revision window and disputed refund case keep this below the strongest support ratings.", "source_ids": [ "S002", "S003" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "An established ongoing practice and multi-year customer record support continuity; it is not one of the longest-tenured firms.", "source_ids": [ "S003", "S004" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "Public professional visibility and a defined editorial practice support standing; self-rankings and review stars are not counted as independent awards.", "source_ids": [ "S001", "S003" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S001", "S002", "S003", "S004" ], "rank": 13, "wins": 12, "losses": 12, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C05", "C02", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C12", "C22", "C21" ] }, { "id": "C22", "name": "Briefcase Coach", "ratings": [ 8, 7.5, 7.5, 9, 8, 8, 8, 7.5, 8 ], "score_exact": 79.25, "score_display": 79, "audience": "Senior executive research-led branding", "advertised_price": "$1,500–$3,200 résumé; broader engagements to $3,900", "strength": "Deep discovery and specific executive client stories", "limitation": "Premium scope; founder involvement is not exclusive authorship", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and selected customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Executive/board resume, LinkedIn, target research and coaching", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Specific executive client accounts support satisfaction, while they remain selected rather than a randomized customer sample.", "source_ids": [ "S110" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "A concrete application/interview account and return/referral themes support benefit; company referral percentages are not audited outcomes.", "source_ids": [ "S110", "S109" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Extensive discovery and research support the premium scope, but entry cost is high and a review session is not a full rewrite.", "source_ids": [ "S097" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Lengthy discovery and executive research create deep customization; supporting writers mean founder involvement is not exclusive founder authorship.", "source_ids": [ "S098", "S109" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Relevant recruiting background and an experienced described team support strong preparation, without assuming universal issuer-certified assignments.", "source_ids": [ "S109" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Research, interviewing and specific customer descriptions support strong process quality; fictionalized samples do not prove actual customer outcomes.", "source_ids": [ "S110", "S098" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "The service explains satisfaction support and client access, without promising a guaranteed job; specific cash-remedy history is limited.", "source_ids": [ "S109" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "An established executive practice and repeat-client pattern support continuity, with less long-term operating history than the oldest firms.", "source_ids": [ "S109" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "Recruiting and educational professional visibility support standing; the company’s own review of itself is not independent recognition.", "source_ids": [ "S109" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S097", "S098", "S109", "S110" ], "rank": 14, "wins": 10, "losses": 13, "ties": 1, "close_neighbors": [ "C02", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C12", "C01", "C21", "C19" ] }, { "id": "C21", "name": "Blue Sky Resumes", "ratings": [ 7.5, 7.5, 8.5, 8.5, 7.5, 8, 8, 9, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 79.25, "score_display": 79, "audience": "Professional, creative and executive careers", "advertised_price": "Professional from $395; executive from $695", "strength": "Experienced team continuity and accessible starting offers", "limitation": "Much independent customer evidence is older", "confidence": "Low", "inspection_coverage": "Before/after approach located; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, LinkedIn, letters and job-search support", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 15.0, "rationale": "Positive customer accounts support the service, but much independent feedback is older. Continuity makes that evidence relevant rather than worthless.", "source_ids": [ "S112", "S096" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Selected career-progress and repeat-use accounts support practical benefit, without a current measured success rate.", "source_ids": [ "S112", "S095" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 12.75, "rationale": "Published starting fees are accessible for a tailored professional service; final scope remains individualized.", "source_ids": [ "S095" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Substantive intake, relevant writer matching and explicit fit boundaries support customization.", "source_ids": [ "S112" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Experienced career-writing personnel and continuity support competence; current external credentials are not established for every writer.", "source_ids": [ "S096" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed writing approach and customer descriptions support a strong process judgment; complete before-and-after documents were not visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S112" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "An explicit customer-contact structure and service-fit approach support care; historical policy language is not assumed to be a current universal refund right.", "source_ids": [ "S095", "S096" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "Long-serving staff continued through the ownership transition, providing stronger continuity than a simple change-of-owner penalty would suggest.", "source_ids": [ "S111", "S096" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "Published writing experience and a longstanding specialist identity support professional standing; current award claims are not independently established.", "source_ids": [ "S096" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S095", "S096", "S111", "S112" ], "rank": 15, "wins": 10, "losses": 13, "ties": 1, "close_neighbors": [ "C02", "C25", "C10", "C06", "C12", "C01", "C22", "C19" ] }, { "id": "C19", "name": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "ratings": [ 8, 7, 7, 8.5, 8, 7.5, 7.5, 9.5, 8.5 ], "score_exact": 77.5, "score_display": 78, "audience": "Federal, military and SES transitions", "advertised_price": "Custom quote; no current official total recovered", "strength": "Long operating history and specialist customer accounts", "limitation": "Current offer access and document inspection incomplete", "confidence": "Low", "inspection_coverage": "Customer/process evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Federal and military resume, SES narratives and transition support", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Recent BBB customer accounts describe accessibility and specialist value, including repeat use.", "source_ids": [ "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Individual outcomes and return engagements support benefit; no service-wide interview or appointment rate is assumed.", "source_ids": [ "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Specialist scope supports a substantive service proposition; price remains quote-based/unknown, so this is a scope-led value judgment, not a cost estimate.", "source_ids": [ "S089", "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Federal and senior-narrative specialization support targeted work; current complete contractual scope was not fully accessible.", "source_ids": [ "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Established specialist experience supports competence, while current assigned-writer issuer status remains incomplete.", "source_ids": [ "S090", "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Specific customer accounts support capable specialist drafting; a complete visual sample was not inspected.", "source_ids": [ "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Accessible support accounts are favorable; the single unpublished BBB complaint cannot establish either wrongdoing or perfect resolution.", "source_ids": [ "S091", "S092" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 4.75, "rationale": "BBB identifies a business history dating to 1986, supporting exceptional operating longevity.", "source_ids": [ "S090" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 4.25, "rationale": "A sustained specialist professional presence is supported by the external business record and federal practice; a blanket endorsement is not inferred.", "source_ids": [ "S090", "S091" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S089", "S090", "S091", "S092" ], "rank": 16, "wins": 9, "losses": 15, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C22", "C21", "C24", "C03", "C08", "C23" ] }, { "id": "C24", "name": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "ratings": [ 7.5, 7.5, 7, 9, 8, 8, 8, 7.5, 7.5 ], "score_exact": 77.25, "score_display": 77, "audience": "STEM, scientific and technical careers", "advertised_price": "Custom quote; unpublished base price not estimated", "strength": "Technical familiarity and sustained personal support", "limitation": "Small outcome sample and no full document inspection", "confidence": "Low", "inspection_coverage": "Process plus one specific outcome account; no full visual sample", "services": "Technical resume, narrative, visibility and interview/negotiation coaching", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 15.0, "rationale": "A named clinical-development client recommendation describes valuable positioning; a separate workshop review is not counted as a résumé engagement.", "source_ids": [ "S114" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "One attributable client describes concurrent offers; the small case set supports benefit but not a high success-rate claim.", "source_ids": [ "S114" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "A substantial, scoped technical engagement and ongoing access support the service proposition; no unpublished base price is estimated.", "source_ids": [ "S102", "S113" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Individual technical discovery, narrative development and follow-up strategy support deep personalization.", "source_ids": [ "S102", "S113" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Relevant scientific/technical background and named delivery support competence; association membership is not mislabeled as NCRW certification.", "source_ids": [ "S104", "S113" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Detailed revision and finalization steps plus specific client observations support strong process quality; no complete résumé was visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S102", "S114" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "Published lifetime email access and check-ins support commitment; this does not establish a measured complaint-resolution rate.", "source_ids": [ "S113" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "A continuing specialized practice supports stability; it is not claimed to have the longest market tenure.", "source_ids": [ "S102", "S104" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "Professional-association participation and technical-career contribution support standing, without an invented industry award.", "source_ids": [ "S104", "S113" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S102", "S104", "S113", "S114" ], "rank": 17, "wins": 8, "losses": 16, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C19", "C03", "C08", "C23" ] }, { "id": "C03", "name": "TopStack Resume", "ratings": [ 8.5, 7, 9, 7.5, 6.5, 7.5, 7.5, 7, 6.5 ], "score_exact": 76.75, "score_display": 77, "audience": "Budget-conscious and early-career buyers", "advertised_price": "$189 Launch; $279 Propel; optional call +$40", "strength": "Low-cost document bundle and draft preview", "limitation": "Optional live intake; certification not required for every writer", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, cover letter, LinkedIn; consultation add-on", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 17.0, "rationale": "Recent named accounts corroborate responsive writing support; large review volume alone receives no bonus.", "source_ids": [ "S108" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Interview and hiring accounts provide evidence of individual benefit, without a résumé-only measured success rate.", "source_ids": [ "S108", "S011" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 13.5, "rationale": "Low published bundle pricing plus an inexpensive optional consultation and draft preview create a strong access/value case.", "source_ids": [ "S010" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Direct correspondence supports customization, but live discovery is an add-on and scope is less intensive than premium engagements.", "source_ids": [ "S010" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "Hiring requires experience and samples; certification is preferred, not mandatory, and the assigned writer remains unidentified before purchase.", "source_ids": [ "S012" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Customer descriptions and draft review support capable delivery; direct full-document craft comparison is unavailable.", "source_ids": [ "S010", "S108" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Preview reduces initial commitment risk; completed services are generally nonrefundable and some BBB disputes concern separate recruiting.", "source_ids": [ "S011", "S013" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 3.5, "rationale": "Active operations and a multi-year public customer record support continuity; depth of long-term practice evidence is more limited.", "source_ids": [ "S013", "S108" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 3.25, "rationale": "A credible market presence is evident; comparable external professional recognition is less developed in the examined record.", "source_ids": [ "S012", "S108" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S010", "S011", "S012", "S013", "S108" ], "rank": 18, "wins": 6, "losses": 17, "ties": 1, "close_neighbors": [ "C19", "C24", "C08", "C23" ] }, { "id": "C08", "name": "The Resume Place", "ratings": [ 7, 7, 7, 8.5, 8.5, 8, 7.5, 9.5, 9 ], "score_exact": 76.75, "score_display": 77, "audience": "Federal and senior federal applicants", "advertised_price": "$210/$260 consultations; complete writing project quoted", "strength": "Deep federal expertise and independent professional recognition", "limitation": "Limited recent writing-customer evidence; total quote required", "confidence": "Low", "inspection_coverage": "Prior federal sample record retained; no new visual inspection", "services": "Federal resume, SES narratives, consultation and training", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 14.0, "rationale": "Available paid-service accounts support relevant expertise, but the independent sample is small and includes older communication disputes.", "source_ids": [ "S040" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "An attributed favorable job outcome and long specialist record support usefulness; books and training attendance are not résumé-purchase results.", "source_ids": [ "S040", "S039" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Federal scope and published consultation fees give a useful basis for engagement, but no complete-project price is invented.", "source_ids": [ "S037" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Federal targeting and senior-service options support specialist customization; full scope depends on the engagement.", "source_ids": [ "S037", "S038" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Deep federal expertise and educational contribution are supported; credentials issued by the firm are identified separately from outside certification.", "source_ids": [ "S039", "S066" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 8.0, "rationale": "A current specialist gallery and documented methodology support the process; prior sample evidence is retained, not presented as new visual testing.", "source_ids": [ "S038" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Defined consulting access provides a support route; current independent resolution evidence is limited and does not justify either zero or perfection.", "source_ids": [ "S037", "S040" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9.5, "weighted_points": 4.75, "rationale": "The association documents an exceptionally long-running federal résumé practice.", "source_ids": [ "S066" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "Independent Industry Hero recognition and university-hosted educational activity support unusually strong professional standing.", "source_ids": [ "S066", "S039" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S037", "S038", "S039", "S040", "S066" ], "rank": 19, "wins": 6, "losses": 17, "ties": 1, "close_neighbors": [ "C19", "C24", "C03", "C23" ] }, { "id": "C23", "name": "Klaxos", "ratings": [ 8, 7, 7.5, 9, 7.5, 7.5, 6.5, 8, 7 ], "score_exact": 75.75, "score_display": 76, "audience": "Founder-led résumé and LinkedIn development", "advertised_price": "Professional page displays $1,198–$1,299 figures", "strength": "Explicit personal consultation and writing commitment", "limitation": "Subscription complaint/no-complaints claim require contextual reporting", "confidence": "Low", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume, LinkedIn, executive biography and toolkit options", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "Detailed source-associated customer accounts support responsiveness and executive positioning; the independent sample is limited.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Selected interview and repeat-use accounts support benefit, without validating an aggregate hiring rate.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "The founder-led package has substantial scope; published price differences are reported as a range, not assumed misconduct or a disqualifying sale.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "The explicit promise of founder consultation and writing creates unusually clear personal accountability.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Relevant founder qualifications are described, but not every advertised credential has current issuer confirmation.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "The process and detailed customer descriptions support a strong working approach; no complete visual document review was completed.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "A toolkit-subscription complaint and a conflicting no-complaints statement create a material commercial-handling concern, not proof of poor résumé drafting.", "source_ids": [ "S100", "S101" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "The operating practice and multi-year public record support established continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S099", "S101" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 3.5, "rationale": "Professional visibility is credible; strong independent award/contribution evidence remains more limited than for the highest-rated specialists.", "source_ids": [ "S099" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S099", "S100", "S101" ], "rank": 20, "wins": 5, "losses": 19, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [ "C19", "C24", "C03", "C08", "C04", "C16" ] }, { "id": "C04", "name": "Resumeble", "ratings": [ 8, 7, 8.5, 7.5, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 7, 6.5 ], "score_exact": 74.5, "score_display": 75, "audience": "Value-focused document bundles", "advertised_price": "$157–$1,197; Professional $297 in retained offer", "strength": "Accessible bundles and responsive writer contact", "limitation": "Some generic sample content; writer identity verification limited", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Selected complete two-page accounting example inspected", "services": "Resume, cover letter, LinkedIn and executive tiers", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 16.0, "rationale": "A substantial independent review record supports attentive service; errors and generic-writing criticisms prevent an exceptional rating.", "source_ids": [ "S017" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "Individual outcome accounts earn credit; the advertised aggregate interview percentage is not treated as measured performance.", "source_ids": [ "S017", "S014" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 12.75, "rationale": "Published document bundles are accessible and reasonably complete for their price; lower-tier live consultation scope is less clear.", "source_ids": [ "S014", "S016" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Assigned-writer contact and revision access support personalization; the depth of live discovery varies or is unclear.", "source_ids": [ "S014" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "The roster describes certified writers, but abbreviated biographies limit issuer matching and assigned-writer accountability.", "source_ids": [ "S015" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 7.0, "rationale": "The inspected accounting example includes useful outcomes alongside generic duty language and inefficient second-page use.", "source_ids": [ "S018", "S019" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Revision and conditional executive remedies are meaningful; they are not universal cash refunds.", "source_ids": [ "S016", "S017" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 3.5, "rationale": "The current service and sustained review footprint support an established practice rather than demonstrated decades of continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S014", "S017" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 3.25, "rationale": "Public visibility is established, but independent professional-contribution evidence is comparatively limited.", "source_ids": [ "S015", "S017" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S014", "S015", "S016", "S017", "S018", "S019" ], "rank": 21, "wins": 3, "losses": 20, "ties": 1, "close_neighbors": [ "C23", "C16" ] }, { "id": "C16", "name": "Resume Target", "ratings": [ 7.5, 6.5, 8, 8.5, 7, 7.5, 7, 9, 6.5 ], "score_exact": 74.5, "score_display": 75, "audience": "Buyers preferring a defined interview length", "advertised_price": "$299 / $349 / $399 / $499; currency unresolved", "strength": "Tiered live consultation and coordinated letter", "limitation": "Thin original-platform evidence; large outcome claim unverified", "confidence": "Low", "inspection_coverage": "Process and customer evidence; no full visual sample", "services": "Resume and cover letter; higher-level consultation and LinkedIn options", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 15.0, "rationale": "The advertised Google footprint and available customer accounts deserve consideration, but original-platform verification and independent coverage are limited.", "source_ids": [ "S075", "S078" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 9.75, "rationale": "Some individual customer evidence supports benefit; the large interview percentage is not a measured success probability for this comparison.", "source_ids": [ "S077", "S078" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "Published tiers include a cover letter and progressively longer consultation; currency is not conclusively established and is not converted.", "source_ids": [ "S075" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 8.5, "weighted_points": 8.5, "rationale": "Defined interview lengths and senior review support a substantive personalized process.", "source_ids": [ "S075", "S076" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 7.0, "rationale": "An employee/senior-review model is described, while the particular writer’s external credentials remain unclear.", "source_ids": [ "S076" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 7.5, "rationale": "Described review and consultation support competent quality control; a complete actual résumé was not visually assessed.", "source_ids": [ "S075", "S076" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 7.0, "rationale": "A rewrite remedy exists, while documented scope disputes and cancellation timing temper the support judgment.", "source_ids": [ "S077", "S078" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "A longstanding operating practice and current tiered service support continuity.", "source_ids": [ "S075", "S076" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 3.25, "rationale": "Public visibility is evident, but independent professional-contribution evidence is less developed than for recognized specialist peers.", "source_ids": [ "S076" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S075", "S076", "S077", "S078" ], "rank": 22, "wins": 3, "losses": 20, "ties": 1, "close_neighbors": [ "C23", "C04" ] }, { "id": "C11", "name": "Resume Professional Writers", "ratings": [ 6.5, 6, 7.5, 6.5, 6.5, 5.5, 6.5, 9, 6 ], "score_exact": 65.75, "score_display": 66, "audience": "Low-cost writing with extensive revision access", "advertised_price": "$125 / $195 / $305 / $485", "strength": "Low entry price and written refund schedule", "limitation": "Concrete grammar and achievement-development weaknesses in sample", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "One financial-analyst page visually inspected; full PDF text retained", "services": "Resume, letters, LinkedIn and higher-tier document bundles", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 13.0, "rationale": "Positive service accounts coexist with grammar, formatting and delivery criticisms; little recent independent feedback limits a stronger assessment.", "source_ids": [ "S054" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 6, "weighted_points": 9.0, "rationale": "Available accounts support some customer benefit, but specific current interview/offer evidence is relatively thin.", "source_ids": [ "S054" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 11.25, "rationale": "Low published fees and broad revisions provide access, but weaker observed craft reduces the value of the inexpensive offer.", "source_ids": [ "S051", "S052" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "Questionnaire, portal and scheduled communication allow customization, with less clearly documented deep discovery.", "source_ids": [ "S051" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "The actual assigned writer and external credential are not clearly identified; the disclosed professional service supports a competent, not elite, rating.", "source_ids": [ "S051" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 5.5, "weighted_points": 5.5, "rationale": "The inspected financial-analyst page is duty-heavy and contains a visible grammatical weakness; this observation is not generalized to every customer.", "source_ids": [ "S053" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "A graduated refund schedule is useful; reported revision and delivery friction limit the overall remedy assessment.", "source_ids": [ "S052", "S054" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 9, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "A longstanding operating service and historical customer record support continuity independent of current writing concerns.", "source_ids": [ "S051", "S054" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 6, "weighted_points": 3.0, "rationale": "Public market presence is established, but strong external professional-contribution evidence is limited in the examined record.", "source_ids": [ "S051", "S054" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S051", "S052", "S053", "S054" ], "rank": 23, "wins": 2, "losses": 22, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [] }, { "id": "C07", "name": "TopResume", "ratings": [ 6.5, 7, 6.5, 6.5, 6.5, 6, 3.5, 7.5, 6.5 ], "score_exact": 62.75, "score_display": 63, "audience": "Broad-market low initial-price writing", "advertised_price": "$179–$599; platform subscription terms separate", "strength": "Accessible packages and some satisfied customers", "limitation": "Documented complaint pattern and inconsistent writer experience", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Selected two-page illustrative marketing example inspected", "services": "Resume, letters, LinkedIn, coaching/platform and recruiting tiers", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 13.0, "rationale": "Many positive customers exist, but visible writer-variation accounts make the satisfaction record materially mixed.", "source_ids": [ "S032" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 7, "weighted_points": 10.5, "rationale": "The commissioned historical study supplies some structured evidence, but compares rewriting with self-written documents, not competing firms.", "source_ids": [ "S035" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 9.75, "rationale": "Accessible initial prices are offset by recurring platform terms and limited revision scope; the sale price itself is not a concern.", "source_ids": [ "S029", "S030" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "Assigned-writer collaboration is available, but standard discovery and identity assurance are less intensive than named-practitioner services.", "source_ids": [ "S029", "S031" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "Writer biographies show relevant experience without establishing uniformly credentialed assignment or direct access to a specific expert.", "source_ids": [ "S031" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 6, "weighted_points": 6.0, "rationale": "The inspected marketing example is organized but uses numerical placeholders; it demonstrates a template rather than fully specific client achievement development.", "source_ids": [ "S036" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 3.5, "weighted_points": 3.5, "rationale": "A BBB pattern alert and specifically attributable unresolved writing/billing disputes warrant a materially low rating; parent totals are not all TopResume cases.", "source_ids": [ "S034" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 7.5, "weighted_points": 3.75, "rationale": "A well-established operating brand and large historical customer footprint support business continuity, separately from service concerns.", "source_ids": [ "S032", "S035" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 3.25, "rationale": "Broad visibility and research activity provide professional presence; prominence and paid promotion do not establish superior craftsmanship.", "source_ids": [ "S031", "S035" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S029", "S030", "S031", "S032", "S034", "S035", "S036" ], "rank": 24, "wins": 1, "losses": 23, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [] }, { "id": "C14", "name": "Resume Writing Group", "ratings": [ 6, 5.5, 6.5, 6.5, 6, 6, 4.5, 8, 5.5 ], "score_exact": 59.75, "score_display": 60, "audience": "Low-cost rapid résumé services", "advertised_price": "$149.95 entry / $189.95 professional / $239.95 executive, retained offers", "strength": "Low advertised fees and revision availability", "limitation": "Billing disputes and restrictive guarantee requirements", "confidence": "Medium", "inspection_coverage": "Historical sample assessment retained; no new visual inspection", "services": "Resume, letters, LinkedIn and optional subscription/distribution services", "criteria": [ { "criterion_id": "feedback", "criterion": "Credible customer feedback", "weight": 20, "rating": 6, "weighted_points": 12.0, "rationale": "The customer record is mixed; repeat business and praise exist alongside service dissatisfaction. Billing-only disputes are not all writing failures.", "source_ids": [ "S070", "S068" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "results", "criterion": "Documented results and track record", "weight": 15, "rating": 5.5, "weighted_points": 8.25, "rationale": "Individual benefit is possible, but the prominent aggregate hiring percentage lacks a usable disclosed method and earns no statistical bonus.", "source_ids": [ "S067", "S070" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "value", "criterion": "Pricing, value and transparency", "weight": 15, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 9.75, "rationale": "Low headline prices are weakened by restrictive guarantee and subscription conditions; ordinary promotions receive no penalty.", "source_ids": [ "S067", "S069" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "personalization", "criterion": "Service depth and personalization", "weight": 10, "rating": 6.5, "weighted_points": 6.5, "rationale": "The service describes customized human writing, but deep discovery and named-author accountability are less visible.", "source_ids": [ "S067" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "credentials", "criterion": "Writer qualifications and credentials", "weight": 10, "rating": 6, "weighted_points": 6.0, "rationale": "Professional staffing is claimed without sufficient assigned-writer credential detail for an elite rating.", "source_ids": [ "S067" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "quality", "criterion": "Quality standards and commitment", "weight": 10, "rating": 6, "weighted_points": 6.0, "rationale": "The retained research describes uneven sample/customer craft evidence; no new complete visual inspection was performed.", "source_ids": [ "S067", "S070" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "resolution", "criterion": "Serious complaints and resolution", "weight": 10, "rating": 4.5, "weighted_points": 4.5, "rationale": "A repeated BBB dispute record and limited confirmed resolutions justify material caution; answered and resolved are not treated as equivalent.", "source_ids": [ "S068" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "history", "criterion": "History and stability", "weight": 5, "rating": 8, "weighted_points": 4.0, "rationale": "Historical operations and repeat-customer evidence support longevity despite current commercial concerns.", "source_ids": [ "S068", "S070" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" }, { "criterion_id": "reputation", "criterion": "Independently supported professional reputation", "weight": 5, "rating": 5.5, "weighted_points": 2.75, "rationale": "Market longevity is evident, but robust external professional recognition is less supported than at specialist peers.", "source_ids": [ "S067", "S070" ], "evidence_status": "INFERRED editorial judgment; underlying source classifications retained" } ], "source_ids": [ "S067", "S068", "S069", "S070" ], "rank": 25, "wins": 0, "losses": 24, "ties": 0, "close_neighbors": [] } ], "sources": [ { "Source ID": "S001", "Title": "Official packages", "Companies": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "URL": "https://www.legresumes.com/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S002", "Title": "Terms", "Companies": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "URL": "https://www.legresumes.com/terms/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S003", "Title": "Independent review profile", "Companies": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.letseatgrandma.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S004", "Title": "Google-source review mirror", "Companies": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "URL": "https://www.trustindex.io/reviews/letseatgrandma.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S005", "Title": "Professional offer", "Companies": "Find My Profession", "URL": "https://www.findmyprofession.com/resume-writing/professional/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Official professional résumé $595; cover letter $100 and LinkedIn $200 advertised bundle add-ons; consultation and seven-day unlimited revisions. Published offer, not a paid test.", "Provenance": "October 25 offer, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S006", "Title": "Portfolio", "Companies": "Find My Profession", "URL": "https://www.findmyprofession.com/resume-samples/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S007", "Title": "Program-manager page 1", "Companies": "Find My Profession", "URL": "https://www.findmyprofession.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Pro-Program-Manager.png", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S008", "Title": "Program-manager page 2", "Companies": "Find My Profession", "URL": "https://www.findmyprofession.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Pro-Program-Manager-2.png", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S009", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "Find My Profession", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/co/golden/profile/resume-services/find-my-profession-inc-1296-90260468/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S010", "Title": "Pricing", "Companies": "TopStack Resume", "URL": "https://www.topstackresume.com/pricing", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S011", "Title": "Remedies", "Companies": "TopStack Resume", "URL": "https://www.topstackresume.com/refunds", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S012", "Title": "Hiring requirements", "Companies": "TopStack Resume", "URL": "https://jobs.gusto.com/postings/topstack-resume-resume-writer-part-time-and-full-time-positions-available-6ebb6cac-c3e8-4886-a092-fcef783e62e3", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S013", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "TopStack Resume", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/nc/chapel-hill/profile/resume-services/topstack-resume-0593-90320403/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S014", "Title": "Packages", "Companies": "Resumeble", "URL": "https://www.resumeble.com/resume-packages", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day official record; refresh unsuccessful", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S015", "Title": "Writer roster", "Companies": "Resumeble", "URL": "https://www.resumeble.com/our-writers", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S016", "Title": "Terms", "Companies": "Resumeble", "URL": "https://www.resumeble.com/terms-condition", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S017", "Title": "Independent reviews", "Companies": "Resumeble", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.resumeble.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S018", "Title": "Accounting page 1", "Companies": "Resumeble", "URL": "https://www.resumeble.com/images/sample-resume/finance.jpg", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S019", "Title": "Accounting page 2", "Companies": "Resumeble", "URL": "https://www.resumeble.com/images/sample-resume/finance-2.png", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S020", "Title": "Prices", "Companies": "ResumeSpice", "URL": "https://resumespice.com/pricing/resumes-cover-letters-interviews-linkedin/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S021", "Title": "FAQ", "Companies": "ResumeSpice", "URL": "https://resumespice.com/about/frequently-asked-questions-about-resume-writers/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S022", "Title": "Current terms", "Companies": "ResumeSpice", "URL": "https://resumespice.com/terms-and-conditions/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S023", "Title": "BBB complaint record", "Companies": "ResumeSpice", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/tx/houston/profile/resume-services/resumespice-0915-90047381/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S024", "Title": "Customer reviews", "Companies": "ResumeSpice", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/resumespice.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day detailed snapshot retained; current sidebar supports approximate rating", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S025", "Title": "Service ranges", "Companies": "Great Resumes Fast", "URL": "https://greatresumesfast.com/services-executive-resume-writers/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S026", "Title": "Alternative starting offer", "Companies": "Great Resumes Fast", "URL": "https://greatresumesfast.com/consult/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day conflicting starting quote; not refreshed", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S027", "Title": "Independent reviews", "Companies": "Great Resumes Fast", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/greatresumesfast.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S028", "Title": "Examined PDF", "Companies": "Great Resumes Fast", "URL": "https://greatresumesfast.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/High-Impact-Marketing-Executive-Resume-1.pdf", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S029", "Title": "Writing tiers", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://topresume.com/resume-writing", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S030", "Title": "FAQ and recurring charge", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://topresume.com/faq", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S031", "Title": "Writer biographies", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://topresume.com/writers", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S032", "Title": "Independent reviews", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/topresume.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S033", "Title": "BBB parent profile", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/resume-services/talent-worldwide-inc-0121-151339", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S034", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/resume-services/talent-worldwide-inc-0121-151339/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S035", "Title": "Historical study", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://topresume.com/career-advice/dollars-sense-of-professional-resume", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S036", "Title": "Sample", "Companies": "TopResume", "URL": "https://topresume.com/samples/resumes/mid-career-professional", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S037", "Title": "Federal fees", "Companies": "The Resume Place", "URL": "https://resume-place.com/federal-resumes/federal-resume-fees/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S038", "Title": "Current gallery", "Companies": "The Resume Place", "URL": "https://resume-place.com/federal-resumes/federal-resume-samples/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S039", "Title": "University event", "Companies": "The Resume Place", "URL": "https://events.georgetown.edu/pivot-with-purpose/event/38146-writing-the-new-2-page-federal-resume/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier cited university event retained; not an endorsement", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S040", "Title": "Customer account source", "Companies": "The Resume Place", "URL": "https://the-resume-place.pissedconsumer.com/review.html", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day account review retained; limited recent sample", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S041", "Title": "Results archive", "Companies": "Ivy League Résumés", "URL": "https://www.ivyleaguecoaching.com/results", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S042", "Title": "Portfolio", "Companies": "Ivy League Résumés", "URL": "https://www.ivyleaguecoaching.com/sample-resumes", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S043", "Title": "Examined COO PDF", "Companies": "Ivy League Résumés", "URL": "https://www.ivyleaguecoaching.com/files/resume-samples/private-equity-chief-operating-officer-resume-sample.pdf", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S044", "Title": "NCRW issuer record", "Companies": "Ivy League Résumés", "URL": "https://thenrwa.org/Sys/PublicProfile/30439154", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S045", "Title": "Columbia profile", "Companies": "Ivy League Résumés", "URL": "https://careercoaches.alumni.columbia.edu/keith_miller", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S046", "Title": "Earlier catalog prices", "Companies": "Ivy League Résumés", "URL": "https://ivyleagueresume.com/knowledge/records/service-page-services.html", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Current top-of-page October 16 prices: $499.95/$599.95/$749.95/$895; historical body prices explicitly superseded. Published direct-service scope and conditional 60-day rewrite/formatting remedy retained. No checkout or actual delivery test.", "Provenance": "October 25 catalog, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S047", "Title": "Bronze scope and terms", "Companies": "JobStars USA", "URL": "https://jobstars.com/product/resume-writing-bronze/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S048", "Title": "Service tiers", "Companies": "JobStars USA", "URL": "https://jobstars.com/resume-writing/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S049", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "JobStars USA", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/il/chicago/profile/career-counseling/jobstars-usa-llc-0654-90008884/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S050", "Title": "BBB customer reviews", "Companies": "JobStars USA", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/il/chicago/profile/career-counseling/jobstars-usa-llc-0654-90008884/customer-reviews", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day detailed customer sample retained", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S051", "Title": "Prices and process", "Companies": "Resume Professional Writers", "URL": "https://www.resumeprofessionalwriters.com/faq/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S052", "Title": "Refund agreement", "Companies": "Resume Professional Writers", "URL": "https://www.resumeprofessionalwriters.com/project-agreement/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S053", "Title": "Sample PDF", "Companies": "Resume Professional Writers", "URL": "https://www.resumeprofessionalwriters.com/resume-example/financial-analyst-resume-example.pdf", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S054", "Title": "Independent reviews", "Companies": "Resume Professional Writers", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.resumeprofessionalwriters.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day detailed review record retained", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S055", "Title": "Professional offers", "Companies": "iCareerSolutions", "URL": "https://icareersolutions.com/professional-resume-writing-services/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S056", "Title": "Terms", "Companies": "iCareerSolutions", "URL": "https://icareersolutions.com/terms-and-conditions/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S057", "Title": "Current BBB profile", "Companies": "iCareerSolutions", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/career-counseling/icareersolutions-0121-87142363", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S058", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "iCareerSolutions", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/career-counseling/icareersolutions-0121-87142363/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S059", "Title": "Independent reviews", "Companies": "iCareerSolutions", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/icareersolutions.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S060", "Title": "Company survey and testimonials", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.distinctiveweb.com/resume-service-reviews/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S061", "Title": "CEO portfolio", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.distinctiveweb.com/project-examples/c-level-executive-resume-example/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S062", "Title": "CEO page 1", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.distinctiveweb.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/C-level-Executive-Resume_Page_1.jpg", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S063", "Title": "CEO page 2", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.distinctiveweb.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/C-level-Executive-Resume_Page_2.jpg", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S064", "Title": "CEO page 3", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.distinctiveweb.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/C-level-Executive-Resume_Page_3.jpg", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S065", "Title": "Issuer directory", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://thenrwa.org/widget/Sys/PublicProfile/8775749", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved issuer profile; old renewal fields leave current renewal unresolved", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S066", "Title": "Professional recognition", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://thenrwa.org/industryheroaward", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S067", "Title": "Current company claims", "Companies": "Resume Writing Group", "URL": "https://www.resumewritinggroup.com/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S068", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "Resume Writing Group", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/wi/jefferson/profile/resume-services/resume-writing-group-0694-1000057847/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S069", "Title": "Linked guarantee document", "Companies": "Resume Writing Group", "URL": "https://www.resumewritinggroup.com/assets/resumewritingterms.pdf", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier captured terms; not newly visually assessed", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S070", "Title": "Independent reviews", "Companies": "Resume Writing Group", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/resumewritinggroup.com", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Earlier same-day detailed review record retained", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S071", "Title": "Expert offer", "Companies": "An Expert Resume", "URL": "https://www.anexpertresume.com/executive-resume-services/expert-package-service/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S072", "Title": "Process and outcome basis", "Companies": "An Expert Resume", "URL": "https://www.anexpertresume.com/faqs/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S073", "Title": "Selected customer accounts", "Companies": "An Expert Resume", "URL": "https://www.anexpertresume.com/executive-resume-writer/laura-smith-proulx-executive-resume-writer-reviews/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S074", "Title": "Portfolio page", "Companies": "An Expert Resume", "URL": "https://www.anexpertresume.com/executive-resume-samples/healthcare-cio-resume/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S075", "Title": "Packages", "Companies": "Resume Target", "URL": "https://www.resumetarget.com/resume-writing-service.php", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S076", "Title": "Writer model", "Companies": "Resume Target", "URL": "https://www.resumetarget.com/our-writers.php", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S077", "Title": "Guarantee", "Companies": "Resume Target", "URL": "https://www.resumetarget.com/90-day-guarantee.php", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S078", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "Resume Target", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/ca/on/toronto/profile/resume-services/resume-target-inc-0107-1244045/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S079", "Title": "Prices and availability", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://writingguru.net/contact-us/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S080", "Title": "Issuer record", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://thenrwa.org/Sys/PublicProfile/12181995/3660697", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S081", "Title": "Company credential claims", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://writingguru.net/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S082", "Title": "Selected reviews", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://writingguru.net/the-writing-guru-wendi-weiner-executive-resume-writer-reviews/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S083", "Title": "Sample disclosures", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://writingguru.net/resume-samples/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S084", "Title": "Current packages", "Companies": "Career Impressions", "URL": "https://careerimpressions.ca/packages/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S085", "Title": "Selected customer outcomes", "Companies": "Career Impressions", "URL": "https://careerimpressions.ca/testimonials/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S086", "Title": "Sample gallery", "Companies": "Career Impressions", "URL": "https://careerimpressions.ca/samples/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S087", "Title": "Examined COO excerpt", "Companies": "Career Impressions", "URL": "https://careerimpressions.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Image-2025-05-14-at-11.56%E2%80%AFAM.jpeg", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S088", "Title": "CERM issuer directory", "Companies": "Career Impressions", "URL": "https://careerdirectors.com/certified-executive-resume-masters-cerm/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S089", "Title": "Official site; access limited", "Companies": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "URL": "https://www.careerproplus.com/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Access incomplete; current official offer not verified", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S090", "Title": "BBB identity", "Companies": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ga/macon/profile/career-counseling/careerpro-global-inc-0743-6495", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S091", "Title": "Customer reviews", "Companies": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ga/macon/profile/career-counseling/careerpro-global-inc-0743-6495/customer-reviews", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S092", "Title": "Complaints", "Companies": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/ga/macon/profile/career-counseling/careerpro-global-inc-0743-6495/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S093", "Title": "Offer, process and source-associated reviews", "Companies": "Career Steering", "URL": "https://careersteering.com/executive-resume-service-writing-services/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S094", "Title": "Official site", "Companies": "Career Steering", "URL": "https://careersteering.com/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S095", "Title": "Prices and services", "Companies": "Blue Sky Resumes", "URL": "https://www.blueskyresumes.com/our-services/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S096", "Title": "Ownership and team continuity", "Companies": "Blue Sky Resumes", "URL": "https://www.blueskyresumes.com/our-team/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile; relevant page reopened in final-scoring pass, not paid delivery testing.", "Provenance": "October 25 evidence, refreshed October 26" }, { "Source ID": "S097", "Title": "Current scope and ranges", "Companies": "Briefcase Coach", "URL": "https://www.briefcasecoach.com/schedule-consultation/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S098", "Title": "Executive service", "Companies": "Briefcase Coach", "URL": "https://www.briefcasecoach.com/executive-resumes/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S099", "Title": "Professional offer", "Companies": "Klaxos", "URL": "https://klaxos.com/services/professional-resume-linkedin-writing/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S100", "Title": "Company FAQ", "Companies": "Klaxos", "URL": "https://klaxos.com/faq/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S101", "Title": "BBB complaints", "Companies": "Klaxos", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/dc/washington/profile/resume-services/klaxos-0241-235999426/complaints", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S102", "Title": "Detailed writing process", "Companies": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "URL": "https://scientechresumes.com/scientech-writing-process/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S103", "Title": "Terms", "Companies": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "URL": "https://scientechresumes.com/scientech-terms-of-service/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S104", "Title": "Association profile", "Companies": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "URL": "https://thenrwa.org/widget/Sys/PublicProfile/39361944/4674619", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S105", "Title": "Recovered executive offer", "Companies": "Employment BOOST", "URL": "https://employmentboost.com/product/executive-resume-writing-package/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S106", "Title": "Current service hub", "Companies": "Employment BOOST", "URL": "https://employmentboost.com/resume-services/", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S107", "Title": "BBB customer-review profile", "Companies": "Employment BOOST", "URL": "https://www.bbb.org/us/mi/troy/profile/resume-services/employment-boost-resume-writers-0372-90037896/customer-reviews", "Checked": "2026-10-25", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved in follow-up; source statements classified in company profile", "Provenance": "Retained from October 25 evidence reassessment" }, { "Source ID": "S108", "Title": "Current customer-review profile", "Companies": "TopStack Resume", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/topstackresume.com", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved October 26; recent named writing-service accounts; not a census or authenticity audit.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S109", "Title": "About and delivery model", "Companies": "Briefcase Coach", "URL": "https://www.briefcasecoach.com/about/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Current company description; referral percentages treated as company-reported.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S110", "Title": "Selected client success stories", "Companies": "Briefcase Coach", "URL": "https://www.briefcasecoach.com/client-success-stories/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Selected role-attributed outcomes; no service-wide success percentage inferred.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S111", "Title": "Ownership and business history", "Companies": "Blue Sky Resumes", "URL": "https://www.blueskyresumes.com/about-us/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Current company account of ownership transition and personnel continuity.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S112", "Title": "Client fit and working process", "Companies": "Blue Sky Resumes", "URL": "https://www.blueskyresumes.com/about-us/are-we-a-good-fit/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Company description and selected client account.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S113", "Title": "New-client service and support model", "Companies": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "URL": "https://scientechresumes.com/new-clients/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Direct service, lifetime email access and post-engagement check-ins are advertised commitments.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S114", "Title": "Public professional recommendations", "Companies": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "URL": "https://www.linkedin.com/in/kateewilliamson", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Search-visible public profile: one clinical-development client reports concurrent offers; a separate workshop recommendation is not a résumé result. Full profile not audited.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S115", "Title": "SHRM vendor-directory customer reviews", "Companies": "Employment BOOST", "URL": "https://vendordirectory.shrm.org/company/818721/reviews", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "89 displayed reviews, 5/5 snapshot. Eight recent named accounts examined; outplacement/coaching and résumé results separated. Anonymous and apparent provider-named entries not used as identified independent clients. Directory listing is not SHRM endorsement.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S116", "Title": "ABA announcement of 2025 award", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2025/09/gp-solo-difference-makers-award-winners/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Primary awarding-body announcement: Wendi Weiner, service-to-profession recognition. Not an award for best résumé service.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S117", "Title": "Current issuer-hosted profile", "Companies": "Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.thenrwa.org/Sys/PublicProfile/8775749/3660697", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "NCOPE renewal April 2027; NCRW marked yes but renewal field June 2024. Current NCRW renewal remains unresolved, not presumed lapsed.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S118", "Title": "Association-hosted professional contribution", "Companies": "Career Steering", "URL": "https://careerdirectors.com/recruiters-call-great-cover-letter/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Historical 2015 contribution and author identification. Not proof of current credential renewal.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S119", "Title": "Author biography and publication record", "Companies": "An Expert Resume", "URL": "https://www.job-hunt.org/author/lsmith-proulx/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Publisher identifies long-term career-writing work and contributions. Historical business dates differ from company branding; no precise founding year asserted in final profile.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S120", "Title": "Awarding association announcement of 2014 TORI results", "Companies": "Career Impressions; An Expert Resume; Career Steering; Distinctive Career Services", "URL": "https://www.prweb.com/releases/career_directors_international_announces_2014_winners_of_the_tori_resume_writing_award_competition/prweb12326042.htm", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Historical primary announcement issued by Career Directors International; awards support professional recognition, not current average delivery or outcomes.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S121", "Title": "Founder background and personal delivery", "Companies": "The Writing Guru", "URL": "https://writingguru.net/wendi-weiner/", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Current company biography; exclusive personal service stated. Claims beyond independently checked records remain company-reported.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S123", "Title": "Current writing and recruiting customer reviews", "Companies": "Find My Profession", "URL": "https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.findmyprofession.com", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Retrieved October 26; 4.8/785 displayed snapshot. Writing-specific accounts separated from reverse recruiting. No authenticity or complete population audit.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" }, { "Source ID": "S122", "Title": "Founder professional-association profile", "Companies": "Great Resumes Fast", "URL": "https://members.parwcc.com/members/?id=61014155", "Checked": "2026-10-26", "Retrieval / evidence note": "Issuer-hosted profile identifies Jessica Hernandez and listed professional credentials. Not verification of every team writer.", "Provenance": "Additional research for final scoring" } ], "matchups": [ { "match_id": 1, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C18", "b": "Career Impressions", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 84.5, "difference": 3.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 2, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C15", "b": "An Expert Resume", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 84.25, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 3, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C13", "b": "Distinctive Career Services", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 82.75, "difference": 5.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+1); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 4, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C17", "b": "The Writing Guru", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 82.5, "difference": 5.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 5, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C20", "b": "Career Steering", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 82.25, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 6, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C05", "b": "ResumeSpice", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 82.0, "difference": 6.25, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 7, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 7.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 8, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 9, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S047 S048 S049 S050", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 10, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 11, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 12, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 8.0, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 13, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 9.0, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 14, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 9.0, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 15, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 10.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 16, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 11.0, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 17, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 11.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Service depth and personalization (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 18, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 11.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 19, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 12.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 20, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 13.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 21, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 13.75, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+3); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 22, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 22.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Quality standards and commitment (+3.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S051 S052 S053 S054", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 23, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 25.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Serious complaints and resolution (+5); Pricing, value and transparency (+3.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S041 S043 S044 S045 S046", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 24, "a_id": "C09", "a": "Ivy League Résumés", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 88.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 28.5, "result": "Ivy League Résumés", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+6); Documented results and track record (+4.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+4)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S041 S043 S044 S045 S046 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 25, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C15", "b": "An Expert Resume", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 84.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S084 S085 S087 S088 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 26, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C13", "b": "Distinctive Career Services", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 82.75, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); History and stability (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S084 S085 S087 S088 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 27, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C17", "b": "The Writing Guru", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 82.5, "difference": 2.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S084 S085 S087 S088 S116 S120 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 28, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C20", "b": "Career Steering", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 82.25, "difference": 2.25, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 29, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C05", "b": "ResumeSpice", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 82.0, "difference": 2.5, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 30, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 31, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S105 S106 S107 S115 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 32, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 33, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 34, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 35, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 4.25, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 36, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 5.25, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S097 S098 S109 S110 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 37, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 5.25, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S095 S096 S111 S112 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 38, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 7.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S089 S090 S091 S092 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 39, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 7.25, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S102 S104 S113 S114 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 40, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Service depth and personalization (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S084 S085 S087 S088 S108 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 41, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 42, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 8.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S084 S085 S087 S088 S099 S100 S101 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 43, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 10.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Service depth and personalization (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 44, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 10.0, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 45, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 18.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 46, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 21.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+4); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 47, "a_id": "C18", "a": "Career Impressions", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 84.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 24.75, "result": "Career Impressions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S084 S085 S087 S088 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 48, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C13", "b": "Distinctive Career Services", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 82.75, "difference": 1.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S071 S072 S073 S117 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 49, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C17", "b": "The Writing Guru", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 82.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S119 S120 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 50, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C20", "b": "Career Steering", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 82.25, "difference": 2.0, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S093 S118 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 51, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C05", "b": "ResumeSpice", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 82.0, "difference": 2.25, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 52, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 3.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 53, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 3.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S105 S106 S107 S115 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 54, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 3.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 55, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 3.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 56, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 3.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 57, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 4.0, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 58, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 5.0, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S097 S098 S109 S110 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 59, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 5.0, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S095 S096 S111 S112 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 60, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 6.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S089 S090 S091 S092 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 61, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 7.0, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S102 S104 S113 S114 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 62, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 7.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Service depth and personalization (+2)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S071 S072 S073 S108 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 63, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 7.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 64, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 8.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S099 S100 S101 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 65, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 9.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Service depth and personalization (+2)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 66, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 9.75, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+3); Credible customer feedback (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S071 S072 S073 S075 S076 S077 S078 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 67, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 18.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 68, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 21.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+4); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 69, "a_id": "C15", "a": "An Expert Resume", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 84.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 24.5, "result": "An Expert Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Documented results and track record (+4.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S071 S072 S073 S119 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 70, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C17", "b": "The Writing Guru", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 82.5, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); History and stability (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S117 S120 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 71, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C20", "b": "Career Steering", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 82.25, "difference": 0.5, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S093 S117 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 72, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C05", "b": "ResumeSpice", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 82.0, "difference": 0.75, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1); History and stability (+1)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 73, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 2.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 74, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S105 S106 S107 S115 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 75, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 76, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 77, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 78, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 2.5, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1); History and stability (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 79, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+1); History and stability (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S097 S098 S109 S110 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 80, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S095 S096 S111 S112 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 81, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 5.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S089 S090 S091 S092 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 82, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 5.5, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1); History and stability (+1)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S102 S104 S113 S114 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 83, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S108 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 84, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 85, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 7.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S099 S100 S101 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 86, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 8.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Quality standards and commitment (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 87, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 8.25, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S075 S076 S077 S078 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 88, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 17.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+3.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 89, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 20.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Quality standards and commitment (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 90, "a_id": "C13", "a": "Distinctive Career Services", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 82.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 23.0, "result": "Distinctive Career Services", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S060 S061 S062 S063 S064 S066 S067 S068 S069 S070 S117 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 91, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C20", "b": "Career Steering", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 82.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S093 S116 S118 S120 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 92, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C05", "b": "ResumeSpice", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 82.0, "difference": 0.5, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 93, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 1.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 94, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S105 S106 S107 S115 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 95, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 96, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 97, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 2.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 98, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 2.25, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 99, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 3.25, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S097 S098 S109 S110 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 100, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 3.25, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S095 S096 S111 S112 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 101, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 5.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S089 S090 S091 S092 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 102, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 5.25, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S102 S104 S113 S114 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 103, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 5.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Service depth and personalization (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S079 S080 S082 S083 S108 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 104, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 5.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 105, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 6.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S079 S080 S082 S083 S099 S100 S101 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 106, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 8.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Service depth and personalization (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 107, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 8.0, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Independently supported professional reputation (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 108, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 16.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+3); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 109, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 19.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 110, "a_id": "C17", "a": "The Writing Guru", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 82.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 22.75, "result": "The Writing Guru", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S079 S080 S082 S083 S116 S121", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 111, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C05", "b": "ResumeSpice", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 82.0, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 112, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 1.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); History and stability (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S093 S118 S120 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 113, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S093 S105 S106 S107 S115 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 114, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 115, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S093 S118 S120 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 116, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 117, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 2.0, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 118, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 3.0, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); History and stability (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S093 S097 S098 S109 S110 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 119, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 3.0, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S093 S095 S096 S111 S112 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 120, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S089 S090 S091 S092 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 121, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 5.0, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S093 S102 S104 S113 S114 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 122, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 5.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S093 S108 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 123, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 5.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 124, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 6.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S093 S099 S100 S101 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 125, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 126, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 7.75, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 127, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 16.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 128, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 19.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 129, "a_id": "C20", "a": "Career Steering", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 82.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 22.5, "result": "Career Steering", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Service depth and personalization (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S093 S118 S120", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 130, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C02", "b": "Find My Profession", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 80.75, "difference": 1.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 131, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 132, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S047 S048 S049 S050", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 133, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S025 S026 S027 S028 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 134, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 1.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 135, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 1.75, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S020 S021 S022 S023 S024", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 136, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 2.75, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 137, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 2.75, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 138, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 4.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 139, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 4.75, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 140, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 5.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 141, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 5.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 142, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 6.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Serious complaints and resolution (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 143, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 7.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S020 S021 S022 S023 S024", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 144, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 7.5, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 145, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 16.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Documented results and track record (+3); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S051 S052 S053 S054", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 146, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 19.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Serious complaints and resolution (+5); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 147, "a_id": "C05", "a": "ResumeSpice", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 82.0, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 22.25, "result": "ResumeSpice", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+6); Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Documented results and track record (+3.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S020 S021 S022 S023 S024 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 148, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C25", "b": "Employment BOOST", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S105 S106 S107 S115 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 149, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S047 S048 S049 S050 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 150, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); History and stability (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S025 S026 S027 S028 S122 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 151, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 152, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 0.5, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S005 S007 S008 S009 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 153, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.5, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S097 S098 S109 S110 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 154, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.5, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S095 S096 S111 S112 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 155, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 3.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S089 S090 S091 S092 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 156, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S102 S104 S113 S114 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 157, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S010 S011 S012 S013 S108 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 158, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 4.0, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 159, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 5.0, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S099 S100 S101 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 160, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 161, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.25, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S075 S076 S077 S078 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 162, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 15.0, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Quality standards and commitment (+3); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S051 S052 S053 S054 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 163, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 18.0, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+4); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 164, "a_id": "C02", "a": "Find My Profession", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 80.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 21.0, "result": "Find My Profession", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S005 S007 S008 S009 S067 S068 S069 S070 S123", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 165, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C10", "b": "JobStars USA", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 166, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S105 S106 S107 S115 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 167, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 168, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 169, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S097 S098 S105 S106 S107 S109 S110 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 170, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S095 S096 S105 S106 S107 S111 S112 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 171, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 3.0, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S089 S090 S091 S092 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 172, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 3.25, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S102 S104 S105 S106 S107 S113 S114 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 173, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Service depth and personalization (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S105 S106 S107 S108 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 174, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 175, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S099 S100 S101 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 176, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 177, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 178, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 179, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 17.75, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 180, "a_id": "C25", "a": "Employment BOOST", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 20.75, "result": "Employment BOOST", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S105 S106 S107 S115", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 181, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C06", "b": "Great Resumes Fast", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S047 S048 S049 S050 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 182, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 183, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S047 S048 S049 S050", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 184, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 185, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 186, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 3.0, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 187, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 3.25, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 188, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S047 S048 S049 S050 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 189, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S047 S048 S049 S050 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 190, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 4.75, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+2); Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 191, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S047 S048 S049 S050", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 192, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 193, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S051 S052 S053 S054", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 194, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 17.75, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+5); Credible customer feedback (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S047 S048 S049 S050", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 195, "a_id": "C10", "a": "JobStars USA", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 20.75, "result": "JobStars USA", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S047 S048 S049 S050 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 196, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C12", "b": "iCareerSolutions", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 197, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S025 S026 S027 S028 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 198, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); History and stability (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S097 S098 S109 S110 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 199, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S095 S096 S111 S112 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 200, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 3.0, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S089 S090 S091 S092 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 201, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 3.25, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S102 S104 S113 S114 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 202, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S025 S026 S027 S028 S108 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 203, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); History and stability (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 204, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S099 S100 S101 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 205, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S025 S026 S027 S028 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 206, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S075 S076 S077 S078 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 207, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Quality standards and commitment (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S051 S052 S053 S054 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 208, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 17.75, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 209, "a_id": "C06", "a": "Great Resumes Fast", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 20.75, "result": "Great Resumes Fast", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3); Serious complaints and resolution (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S025 S026 S027 S028 S067 S068 S069 S070 S122", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 210, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C01", "b": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 80.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 211, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); History and stability (+0.25)", "b_advantages": "Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 212, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.25, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 213, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 3.0, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 214, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 3.25, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 215, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 216, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.75, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 217, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 4.75, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 218, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 219, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 6.0, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 220, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 221, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 17.75, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S055 S056 S057 S058 S059", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 222, "a_id": "C12", "a": "iCareerSolutions", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 80.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 20.75, "result": "iCareerSolutions", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S055 S056 S057 S058 S059 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 223, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C22", "b": "Briefcase Coach", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.0, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 224, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 1.0, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 225, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 2.75, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 226, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 3.0, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 227, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S010 S011 S012 S013 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 228, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Documented results and track record (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 229, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 4.5, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 230, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 5.75, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 231, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 5.75, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 232, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 14.5, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Documented results and track record (+3); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S051 S052 S053 S054", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 233, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 17.5, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 234, "a_id": "C01", "a": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 80.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 20.5, "result": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Documented results and track record (+3.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S001 S002 S003 S004 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 235, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C21", "b": "Blue Sky Resumes", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 79.25, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S095 S096 S097 S098 S109 S110 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 236, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S089 S090 S091 S092 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 237, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 2.0, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S097 S098 S102 S104 S109 S110 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 238, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 2.5, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S097 S098 S108 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 239, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 2.5, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 240, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S097 S098 S099 S100 S101 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 241, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 242, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 243, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 13.5, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 244, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 16.5, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 245, "a_id": "C22", "a": "Briefcase Coach", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 19.5, "result": "Briefcase Coach", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S097 S098 S109 S110", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 246, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C19", "b": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 77.5, "difference": 1.75, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S089 S090 S091 S092 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 247, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 2.0, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); History and stability (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S095 S096 S102 S104 S111 S112 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 248, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 2.5, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+1)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S095 S096 S108 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 249, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 2.5, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 250, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 3.5, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S095 S096 S099 S100 S101 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 251, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 252, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 4.75, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 253, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 13.5, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 254, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 16.5, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 255, "a_id": "C21", "a": "Blue Sky Resumes", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 79.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 19.5, "result": "Blue Sky Resumes", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S095 S096 S111 S112", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 256, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C24", "b": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 77.25, "difference": 0.25, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S089 S090 S091 S092 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 257, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 0.75, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); History and stability (+1.25); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S089 S090 S091 S092 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 258, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 0.75, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 259, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 1.75, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1); History and stability (+0.75); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S089 S090 S091 S092 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 260, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 3.0, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); History and stability (+1.25); Service depth and personalization (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 261, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 3.0, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 262, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 11.75, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2); Quality standards and commitment (+2)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 263, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 264, "a_id": "C19", "a": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 77.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 17.75, "result": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Serious complaints and resolution (+3); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S089 S090 S091 S092", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 265, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C03", "b": "TopStack Resume", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 0.5, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S102 S104 S108 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 266, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 0.5, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 267, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 1.5, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S099 S100 S101 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 268, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 2.75, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 269, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 2.75, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 270, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 11.5, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+2.5); Quality standards and commitment (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); History and stability (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 271, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 14.5, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4.5); Service depth and personalization (+2.5); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 272, "a_id": "C24", "a": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 77.25, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 17.5, "result": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S102 S104 S113 S114", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 273, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C08", "b": "The Resume Place", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 76.75, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+3)", "b_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); History and stability (+1.25); Independently supported professional reputation (+1.25)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 274, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 1.0, "result": "TopStack Resume", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S099 S100 S101 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 275, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "TopStack Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 276, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "TopStack Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); History and stability (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S075 S076 S077 S078 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 277, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 11.0, "result": "TopStack Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Quality standards and commitment (+2)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S051 S052 S053 S054 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 278, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 14.0, "result": "TopStack Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+3.75)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 279, "a_id": "C03", "a": "TopStack Resume", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 17.0, "result": "TopStack Resume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+5); Pricing, value and transparency (+3.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S010 S011 S012 S013 S067 S068 S069 S070 S108", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 280, "a_id": "C08", "a": "The Resume Place", "b_id": "C23", "b": "Klaxos", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 75.75, "difference": 1.0, "result": "The Resume Place", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Serious complaints and resolution (+1); Independently supported professional reputation (+1)", "b_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 281, "a_id": "C08", "a": "The Resume Place", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "The Resume Place", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+2); History and stability (+1.25); Independently supported professional reputation (+1.25)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 282, "a_id": "C08", "a": "The Resume Place", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 2.25, "result": "The Resume Place", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Writer qualifications and credentials (+1.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+1.25); Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 283, "a_id": "C08", "a": "The Resume Place", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 11.0, "result": "The Resume Place", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+2.5); Service depth and personalization (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S051 S052 S053 S054 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 284, "a_id": "C08", "a": "The Resume Place", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 14.0, "result": "The Resume Place", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Service depth and personalization (+2); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S037 S038 S039 S040 S066", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 285, "a_id": "C08", "a": "The Resume Place", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 76.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 17.0, "result": "The Resume Place", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+3); Writer qualifications and credentials (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S037 S038 S039 S040 S066 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 286, "a_id": "C23", "a": "Klaxos", "b_id": "C04", "b": "Resumeble", "a_score": 75.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 1.25, "result": "Klaxos", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1.5); Writer qualifications and credentials (+1); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Serious complaints and resolution (+1)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 287, "a_id": "C23", "a": "Klaxos", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 75.75, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 1.25, "result": "Klaxos", "separation": "Close editorial call", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Service depth and personalization (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75); Serious complaints and resolution (+0.5); History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S075 S076 S077 S078 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 288, "a_id": "C23", "a": "Klaxos", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 75.75, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 10.0, "result": "Klaxos", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5); Quality standards and commitment (+2)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 289, "a_id": "C23", "a": "Klaxos", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 75.75, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 13.0, "result": "Klaxos", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Serious complaints and resolution (+3); Service depth and personalization (+2.5)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 290, "a_id": "C23", "a": "Klaxos", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 75.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 16.0, "result": "Klaxos", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Service depth and personalization (+2.5); Documented results and track record (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S099 S100 S101", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 291, "a_id": "C04", "a": "Resumeble", "b_id": "C16", "b": "Resume Target", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 74.5, "difference": 0.0, "result": "Tie", "separation": "Exact score tie", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+1); Documented results and track record (+0.75); Pricing, value and transparency (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Service depth and personalization (+1); History and stability (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 292, "a_id": "C04", "a": "Resumeble", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 8.75, "result": "Resumeble", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Documented results and track record (+1.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+1)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S051 S052 S053 S054", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 293, "a_id": "C04", "a": "Resumeble", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 11.75, "result": "Resumeble", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+4); Credible customer feedback (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 294, "a_id": "C04", "a": "Resumeble", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "Resumeble", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+4); Pricing, value and transparency (+3); Serious complaints and resolution (+3)", "b_advantages": "History and stability (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S014 S015 S016 S017 S018 S019 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 295, "a_id": "C16", "a": "Resume Target", "b_id": "C11", "b": "Resume Professional Writers", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 65.75, "difference": 8.75, "result": "Resume Target", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+2); Service depth and personalization (+2); Quality standards and commitment (+2)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 296, "a_id": "C16", "a": "Resume Target", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 11.75, "result": "Resume Target", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+3.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+2)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+0.75)", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 297, "a_id": "C16", "a": "Resume Target", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 74.5, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 14.75, "result": "Resume Target", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Credible customer feedback (+3); Serious complaints and resolution (+2.5); Pricing, value and transparency (+2.25)", "b_advantages": "No positive weighted category advantage", "source_ids": "S067 S068 S069 S070 S075 S076 S077 S078", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 298, "a_id": "C11", "a": "Resume Professional Writers", "b_id": "C07", "b": "TopResume", "a_score": 65.75, "b_score": 62.75, "difference": 3.0, "result": "Resume Professional Writers", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+3); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); History and stability (+0.75)", "b_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+1.5); Quality standards and commitment (+0.5); Independently supported professional reputation (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S051 S052 S053 S054", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 299, "a_id": "C11", "a": "Resume Professional Writers", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 65.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 6.0, "result": "Resume Professional Writers", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+2); Pricing, value and transparency (+1.5); Credible customer feedback (+1)", "b_advantages": "Quality standards and commitment (+0.5)", "source_ids": "S051 S052 S053 S054 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." }, { "match_id": 300, "a_id": "C07", "a": "TopResume", "b_id": "C14", "b": "Resume Writing Group", "a_score": 62.75, "b_score": 59.75, "difference": 3.0, "result": "TopResume", "separation": "Model preference", "a_advantages": "Documented results and track record (+2.25); Credible customer feedback (+1); Writer qualifications and credentials (+0.5)", "b_advantages": "Serious complaints and resolution (+1); History and stability (+0.25)", "source_ids": "S029 S030 S031 S032 S034 S035 S036 S067 S068 S069 S070", "interpretation": "Derived comparison of the same rubric; not a separate service test." } ], "scenarios": { "Baseline": [ 20, 15, 15, 10, 10, 10, 10, 5, 5 ], "Craft and credentials": [ 15, 15, 10, 10, 15, 20, 10, 2.5, 2.5 ], "Customer experience": [ 30, 20, 10, 10, 5, 10, 10, 2.5, 2.5 ], "Budget and access": [ 20, 10, 30, 10, 5, 10, 10, 2.5, 2.5 ], "Equal criteria": [ 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111, 11.11111111111111 ] }, "sensitivity": [ { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C09", "company": "Ivy League Résumés", "score": 88.25, "rank": 1 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C18", "company": "Career Impressions", "score": 84.5, "rank": 2 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C15", "company": "An Expert Resume", "score": 84.25, "rank": 3 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C13", "company": "Distinctive Career Services", "score": 82.75, "rank": 4 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C17", "company": "The Writing Guru", "score": 82.5, "rank": 5 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C20", "company": "Career Steering", "score": 82.25, "rank": 6 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C05", "company": "ResumeSpice", "score": 82.0, "rank": 7 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C02", "company": "Find My Profession", "score": 80.75, "rank": 8 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C25", "company": "Employment BOOST", "score": 80.5, "rank": 9 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C10", "company": "JobStars USA", "score": 80.5, "rank": 10 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C06", "company": "Great Resumes Fast", "score": 80.5, "rank": 11 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C12", "company": "iCareerSolutions", "score": 80.5, "rank": 12 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C01", "company": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "score": 80.25, "rank": 13 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C22", "company": "Briefcase Coach", "score": 79.25, "rank": 14 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C21", "company": "Blue Sky Resumes", "score": 79.25, "rank": 15 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C19", "company": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "score": 77.5, "rank": 16 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C24", "company": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "score": 77.25, "rank": 17 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C03", "company": "TopStack Resume", "score": 76.75, "rank": 18 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C08", "company": "The Resume Place", "score": 76.75, "rank": 19 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C23", "company": "Klaxos", "score": 75.75, "rank": 20 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C04", "company": "Resumeble", "score": 74.5, "rank": 21 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C16", "company": "Resume Target", "score": 74.5, "rank": 22 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C11", "company": "Resume Professional Writers", "score": 65.75, "rank": 23 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C07", "company": "TopResume", "score": 62.75, "rank": 24 }, { "scenario": "Baseline", "company_id": "C14", "company": "Resume Writing Group", "score": 59.75, "rank": 25 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C09", "company": "Ivy League Résumés", "score": 88.75, "rank": 1 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C18", "company": "Career Impressions", "score": 85.0, "rank": 2 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C15", "company": "An Expert Resume", "score": 84.375, "rank": 3 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C13", "company": "Distinctive Career Services", "score": 83.5, "rank": 4 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C17", "company": "The Writing Guru", "score": 83.5, "rank": 5 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C20", "company": "Career Steering", "score": 82.25, "rank": 6 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C05", "company": "ResumeSpice", "score": 81.5, "rank": 7 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C02", "company": "Find My Profession", "score": 81.25, "rank": 8 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C06", "company": "Great Resumes Fast", "score": 80.875, "rank": 9 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C12", "company": "iCareerSolutions", "score": 80.875, "rank": 10 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C25", "company": "Employment BOOST", "score": 80.375, "rank": 11 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C10", "company": "JobStars USA", "score": 80.125, "rank": 12 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C01", "company": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "score": 79.75, "rank": 13 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C22", "company": "Briefcase Coach", "score": 79.625, "rank": 14 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C21", "company": "Blue Sky Resumes", "score": 78.875, "rank": 15 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C24", "company": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "score": 78.25, "rank": 16 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C08", "company": "The Resume Place", "score": 77.375, "rank": 17 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C19", "company": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "score": 77.0, "rank": 18 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C23", "company": "Klaxos", "score": 75.5, "rank": 19 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C03", "company": "TopStack Resume", "score": 75.375, "rank": 20 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C16", "company": "Resume Target", "score": 73.875, "rank": 21 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C04", "company": "Resumeble", "score": 73.125, "rank": 22 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C11", "company": "Resume Professional Writers", "score": 63.75, "rank": 23 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C07", "company": "TopResume", "score": 62.0, "rank": 24 }, { "scenario": "Craft and credentials", "company_id": "C14", "company": "Resume Writing Group", "score": 59.125, "rank": 25 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C09", "company": "Ivy League Résumés", "score": 88.5, "rank": 1 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C15", "company": "An Expert Resume", "score": 84.375, "rank": 2 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C18", "company": "Career Impressions", "score": 84.25, "rank": 3 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C05", "company": "ResumeSpice", "score": 83.5, "rank": 4 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C20", "company": "Career Steering", "score": 82.5, "rank": 5 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C13", "company": "Distinctive Career Services", "score": 82.0, "rank": 6 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C17", "company": "The Writing Guru", "score": 82.0, "rank": 7 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C02", "company": "Find My Profession", "score": 81.25, "rank": 8 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C10", "company": "JobStars USA", "score": 81.125, "rank": 9 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C01", "company": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "score": 81.0, "rank": 10 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C25", "company": "Employment BOOST", "score": 80.875, "rank": 11 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C06", "company": "Great Resumes Fast", "score": 80.125, "rank": 12 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C12", "company": "iCareerSolutions", "score": 80.125, "rank": 13 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C22", "company": "Briefcase Coach", "score": 79.375, "rank": 14 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C21", "company": "Blue Sky Resumes", "score": 78.375, "rank": 15 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C03", "company": "TopStack Resume", "score": 77.625, "rank": 16 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C24", "company": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "score": 77.25, "rank": 17 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C19", "company": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "score": 77.0, "rank": 18 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C23", "company": "Klaxos", "score": 76.0, "rank": 19 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C04", "company": "Resumeble", "score": 75.125, "rank": 20 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C08", "company": "The Resume Place", "score": 74.875, "rank": 21 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C16", "company": "Resume Target", "score": 73.875, "rank": 22 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C11", "company": "Resume Professional Writers", "score": 64.5, "rank": 23 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C07", "company": "TopResume", "score": 62.75, "rank": 24 }, { "scenario": "Customer experience", "company_id": "C14", "company": "Resume Writing Group", "score": 58.875, "rank": 25 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C09", "company": "Ivy League Résumés", "score": 89.0, "rank": 1 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C18", "company": "Career Impressions", "score": 83.75, "rank": 2 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C05", "company": "ResumeSpice", "score": 82.5, "rank": 3 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C15", "company": "An Expert Resume", "score": 82.375, "rank": 4 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C01", "company": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "score": 81.5, "rank": 5 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C02", "company": "Find My Profession", "score": 81.25, "rank": 6 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C10", "company": "JobStars USA", "score": 81.125, "rank": 7 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C20", "company": "Career Steering", "score": 81.0, "rank": 8 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C13", "company": "Distinctive Career Services", "score": 81.0, "rank": 9 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C25", "company": "Employment BOOST", "score": 80.875, "rank": 10 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C06", "company": "Great Resumes Fast", "score": 80.625, "rank": 11 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C12", "company": "iCareerSolutions", "score": 80.625, "rank": 12 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C21", "company": "Blue Sky Resumes", "score": 80.375, "rank": 13 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C03", "company": "TopStack Resume", "score": 80.125, "rank": 14 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C17", "company": "The Writing Guru", "score": 80.0, "rank": 15 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C22", "company": "Briefcase Coach", "score": 78.875, "rank": 16 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C04", "company": "Resumeble", "score": 77.125, "rank": 17 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C24", "company": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "score": 76.25, "rank": 18 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C23", "company": "Klaxos", "score": 76.0, "rank": 19 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C19", "company": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "score": 76.0, "rank": 20 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C16", "company": "Resume Target", "score": 75.875, "rank": 21 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C08", "company": "The Resume Place", "score": 74.875, "rank": 22 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C11", "company": "Resume Professional Writers", "score": 67.0, "rank": 23 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C07", "company": "TopResume", "score": 62.25, "rank": 24 }, { "scenario": "Budget and access", "company_id": "C14", "company": "Resume Writing Group", "score": 60.375, "rank": 25 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C09", "company": "Ivy League Résumés", "score": 87.2222, "rank": 1 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C15", "company": "An Expert Resume", "score": 85.0, "rank": 2 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C18", "company": "Career Impressions", "score": 85.0, "rank": 3 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C13", "company": "Distinctive Career Services", "score": 85.0, "rank": 4 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C17", "company": "The Writing Guru", "score": 84.4444, "rank": 5 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C20", "company": "Career Steering", "score": 82.7778, "rank": 6 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C06", "company": "Great Resumes Fast", "score": 81.1111, "rank": 7 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C05", "company": "ResumeSpice", "score": 80.5556, "rank": 8 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C12", "company": "iCareerSolutions", "score": 80.5556, "rank": 9 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C25", "company": "Employment BOOST", "score": 80.0, "rank": 10 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C02", "company": "Find My Profession", "score": 80.0, "rank": 11 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C10", "company": "JobStars USA", "score": 80.0, "rank": 12 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C21", "company": "Blue Sky Resumes", "score": 80.0, "rank": 13 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C08", "company": "The Resume Place", "score": 80.0, "rank": 14 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C22", "company": "Briefcase Coach", "score": 79.4444, "rank": 15 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C19", "company": "CareerProPlus / CareerPro Global", "score": 79.4444, "rank": 16 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C01", "company": "Let’s Eat, Grandma", "score": 78.8889, "rank": 17 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C24", "company": "Scientech Resumes / Scientech Career Systems", "score": 77.7778, "rank": 18 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C23", "company": "Klaxos", "score": 75.5556, "rank": 19 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C16", "company": "Resume Target", "score": 75.0, "rank": 20 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C03", "company": "TopStack Resume", "score": 74.4444, "rank": 21 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C04", "company": "Resumeble", "score": 72.7778, "rank": 22 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C11", "company": "Resume Professional Writers", "score": 66.6667, "rank": 23 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C07", "company": "TopResume", "score": 62.7778, "rank": 24 }, { "scenario": "Equal criteria", "company_id": "C14", "company": "Resume Writing Group", "score": 60.5556, "rank": 25 } ], "disclosure": "This comparison was commissioned by Keith Lawrence Miller, owner of Ivy League Résumés, one of the companies evaluated. AI-assisted public-source research and editorial scoring were used. It is not an independent consumer-testing study. No service was purchased or company contacted for this comparison.", "score_type": "Editorial assessment, not a customer star rating, measured success probability, causal estimate or statistical confidence interval.", "missing_data_policy": "No numerical zero or neutral default is assigned simply because a field is unknown. Ratings judge the available, identified evidence in each category. Incomplete direct output or price evidence is marked explicitly and lowers confidence in that judgment, not through a hidden arithmetic deduction. A quote-based value score is scope/terms-led and does not claim a known price.", "sample_coverage": "Eight selected examples totaling 15 visible pages were examined in the retained October 25 audit. This final pass adds source research, not new visual service tests. Remaining quality ratings draw on process and specific customer descriptions and are labeled accordingly.", "tournament_policy": "All 300 unique pairs are compared on the unrounded baseline score. Equal totals are ties; final rank uses outcomes, feedback, value, then evidence confidence. A residual tie is displayed alphabetically, an administrative ordering with no quality advantage claimed. Nonzero gaps below two points are close editorial calls. No claim of statistical significance is made.", "rank_precision": "Display totals are rounded to whole points; exact arithmetic is retained only to make the model reproducible. Neighboring positions can change under reasonable judgment changes.", "original_files_preserved": true, "publication_state": "Prepared locally, not published." }